Quick post on Halloween night.
Here's an article which was forwarded to me by my friend Lee, a former Marine officer in the JAG Corps who used to work under Lt. Col Colbey Volkey out at Camp Pendleton. Lee says that Volkey is a really good guy and a great Marine (a claim which the article seems to support). Anyway, after years of service in the Marine Corps and in the JAG Corps in particular, Volkey is leaving the Marine Corps because of what he sees as essentially corruption within the military justice system. It sounds like Volkey has had problems with commanding officers trying to influence the outcome of judicial proceedings (through everything from influencing juries to stacking prosecution teams to selectively filing charges in the first place), and that he believes that he has seen soldiers being railroaded (or something that sounds awfully close to it) in cases of alleged misconduct in Iraq when it looks like a proper defense of the soldiers in those situations might call into question the orders that the soldiers were operating under. Apparently higher ranking officers aren't too happy about cases or legal defenses (especially effective ones) which might call into question the command decisions of these higher ranking officers and/or policymaking individuals (It may be unfair to punish soldiers when they were trying to execute ambiguous orders to the best of their ability in an extremely difficult situation that they shouldn't have been placed into in the first place. When bad things happen as a result of soldiers carrying out their orders, who's to blame?).
Anyway, the article merits a look. I'm pretty sure that Colbey isn't exactly a bleeding heart liberal, but it sounds to me like he's tired of seeing footsoldiers sacrificed for the protection of commanders who are making bad decisions. Then again, the first bad command decision was probably getting our troops involved in an occupation and guerrilla war against indigent insurgents in the first place (big surprise- I'm looking at you, George). He's also tired of seeing soldiers come back from serving overseas who have developed significant mental health problems (typically as a result of post traumatic stress disorder) who are then treated as discipline problems by the military rather than getting the help that they deserve, and he's worked within the military justice system at Guantanamo Bay and come away from the experience describing the system as "horrific" and "a sham".
Interesting perspective from a guy who has put in a lot of years serving his country. Maybe we owe our troops a little more help than they're getting. We definitely owe them a justice system which staunchly upholds the constitution that they're fighting to defend.
No comments:
Post a Comment