Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Great. We're evil.

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

What is worse:
1. Keeping the option open to make terrorists uncomfortable in the effort to save lives.
2. Giving America's secrets to the Washington Post to promote America as "evil" and further alienate the world...all in an effort to discredit the President and gain political power. By the way, the interrogation techniques so often called "torture" existed under Bill Clinton and long before him as well.

The League said...

I find it interesting that the President who ran on his appeal as a man of faith believes that the right path is to torture other people and commit by proxy inhumane acts as a matter of course and continues to receive support from men of the cloth like Robert Schuller.

J.S. said...

1. We're going to fight terrorism by being as bad as the terrorists?
2. Having a transparent government is one of the hallmarks of an effective democracy, not treason. This administration has soundly thrashed that ideal. And, no, I don't believe this type of torture was condoned as legal under the Clinton administration.

"Those who go out to fight monsters should beware, lest a monster they become." (paraphrased)
-Nietzsche

Anonymous said...

1. No, we will not be as bad as the terrorists. We will not send suicide bombers to target innocent men, women, and children. Instead, we will hunt down and kill those who do. Please tell me you can see the difference. No, we will not torture. There is no evidence that we ever have.
2. Are you suggesting that America surrender its secrets in the name of transparent government? I'm sure North Korea, Iran, Russia and al-Qaida would like that as well.

Agressive interrogation such as sleep deprivation, water boarding, and other psychological techniques were legal under the Clinton administration and long before. Secrets back then were still secrets, not political ammunition.

It is also true that the President has gone on the record over and over again saying that we don't torture. Still, the mainstream media, with no evidence, says he tortures terrorists. There is no evidence for such allegations.

The League said that the President "believes that the right path is to torture." The President has very often said, "WE DO NOT TORTURE." There is no evidence to contradict the President. So, where does this kind of talk come from? In answering this question, please don't purport that the President, Sec Def, or anyone else ordered Abu Ghraib. If so, Privates and Corporals would not have been carrying out the orders. That's ridiculous.

And please don't bring up Gitmo, the most transparent and scrutenized prison in the world. People still say that it is inhumane and want to shut it down. On what grounds? Every Democrat in Congress is welcome to visit any time and they do. Every civil liberties group in the world has been invited to visit. None have turned up any inhumane treatment.

The media and certain politicians are making moves to silence voices of reason. Has true liberalism died?

"Those who go out to fight monsters should beware, for the monster may be at home."
-Anonymous

The League said...

So Alberto and George were just passing secret notes back and forth for no reason? That's cute.

You know, when you base your argument on the fact that what the president or government says is fact, and you're sticking by it, it doesn't make for a terrifically reasonable argument. Let alone denying a fairly well documented pattern of behavior in order to make an argument. I've heard and read reports of secret prisons, seen photos and stories from Abu Ghraib, etc... I'm not sure how you're claiming none of this exists...

Further, when you intentionally distort the point someone else is making (yes, Jason was suggesting that we give up government secrets to give the advantage to terrorists. Insert roll of eyes here.), it makes for a weak argument.

You're not really making any viable points.

thevike13 said...

1. Really? We don't kill innocent women and children? You're right. We don't have suicide bombers. We pay private contractor military companies billions so they can do it for us. You don't trust the media. Neither do I. Watch CSPAN this week. I'm sure they will replay the Black Water hearings. They are nothing more than mercenaries. Thugs, that don't have to follow the military code of justice, or geneva conventions. $5k a body. $5k a body. They shoot an innocent woman, child, or male civilian than the state department pays the family $5k a body. Is that what your life is worth? Your family? Your friends? If you and I were born in Iraq more than likely we would be dead. Regardless of whether we were civilians or insurgents.

Is that what a human life is worth? A measly $5k. I'll tell you what. Every single member of my family and all of my friends are worth far more than $5k. They are priceless. These thugs kill innocents, and then aren't even punished. The CEO of Blackwater said that one guy's punishment for killing civilians was that he didn't get his Thanksgiving and Christmas bonus. Are you kidding me? He doesn't get his Christmas bonus. That's his punishment? And people wonder why more and more insurgents join the fight against us. It's no surprise to me. The media doesn't have to promote as evil. Our government does it for us.

You don't know anyone in the military, do you? If you do. Shame on you. If you don't then I can understand your position (you could care less about our troops).

Torturing only undermines our own troops safety. There was an internal email from Black Water that was leaked in which an employee was happy that the military would get blamed for a civilian death instead of Black Water. These thugs are disgracing and dishonoring our country. Our country which has already been disgraced enough by this administration.

J.S. said...

Yeah, this administration has engaged in way too much fear mongering and hidden behind the excuse of "national security" way too many times while implementing illegal programs, abandoning the constitution, and violating the Geneva Convention. Anyone can be labeled an "enemy combatant" or a terrorist at any given time, and the next thing you know they're subject to the use of physical and psychological abuse (including freezing temperatures, water torture, and physical assault)? I just don't trust my government (in particular, the military and our intelligence services) enough to let them unilaterally make decisions like that. We used to be looked at as world leaders in terms of ethics, human rights, and the rule of law on the world stage. The end goal is supposed to be an entire planet in which torture and inhuman treatment is considered illegal and cruel, and I think we need to be leaders in the pursuit of that end. I think that we win nothing if we give up what it meant to be Americans in the first place in order to fight the bad guys. The fight against terrorism might take longer if we resist the urge to inhumanely cut corners, but it will still be winnable, and we need to prove that to the world by sticking to our principles.

Anonymous said...

hello

Anonymous said...

To The League:
You know, when you present your argument without any evidence, it doesn't make for a terrifically reasonable argument. I am not sure how you are suggesting that anyone has ever been tortured. I am looking forward to the evidence.

I wasn't distorting any facts. It seems Steanso is content with individuals disclosing America's long held secrets in the name of transparent government.

To Steanso:
I appreciate your willingness to fight the war on terror. I wish you wouldn't use the word torture. The President's policy is not to torture...unless you have some evidence otherwise.

To Shadow:
I am hurt that you would suggest I don't care about our troops. I am appalled that you would suggest I don't know any. It is ok, though. I am getting used to allegations with no evidence.

thevike13 said...

So am I.

thevike13 said...

Just like Clinton said he didn't have sexual relations with that women. The Bush Administration doesn't "torture" terrorists. They make them uncomfortable. Fine. They pay millions to private contractors to make terrorists uncomfortable.

Your second point also makes no sense to me. If we don't "torture" terrorists than what "secrets" did the Washington Post leak? If we aren't making terrorists "uncomfortable", then why did Gonzales resign? Why did he fire all of those US attorneys? If we are leading the charge for truth and justice why did all this occur? Why is there awful smell coming from the "Justice" Department and The White House.

While you wait for evidence from the League, I will wait for you to provide me with evidence that making terrorists "uncomfortable" has saved one American life. I keep hearing this argument, yet not one single person who has argued this has ever shown me one example. I will also wait for evidence that locking people away without due process has saved one American life. I think the main point that Steanso and I are trying to make is:

are we a country that supports freedom across this globe or are we a country that supports oppression?

I keep hearing that our troops our fighting for our freedoms, yet this administration has continued to try to destroy freedom. They have made every attempt to destroy our Constitution and Bill of Rights. It makes no sense.

I don't trust our government. I haven't trusted our government for a very long time (yes, going back to Clinton and Bush Sr, although the old man was a far superior president to his idiot, spoiled son). I could be tagged a terrorist for writing this. I could then disappear, and there wouldn't be anything that my family and friends could do about it. I don't trust a government that gives millions to private contractors who hire foreign nationals to do our dirty work.

Why haven't we done anything in Darfur? There is religious war and genocide going on there, yet this government could care less. I wonder why this is? Could it be that Africa has very little oil? Could it be that Africa is a poor country? Could it be that Africa is not a strategic position to occupy?

I'm sorry that I hurt your feelings with my assumption that you didn't care for our troops. In defense of myself, it's hard for me not to think that when you blindly follow this President. I'll bet you didn't believe a word Clinton said when he was President, yet with Bush everything is the honest truth. If that is not the case, and you did believe everything Clinton said then I at least have to tip my cap to you for being consistent and non-partisan. We need more citizens to look beyond the D and R next to a politicans name. I doubt that's the case with you though (please, please correct me if I'm wrong). If Bush were a democrat I would hate him and his policies just as much as I do now. I think our two party system is failing this country in a big way. I think the Democrats are a poor excuse for a party and have no backbone.

This President and his administration could care less about our troops. Don't take it from me (I'm not a vet, but I have friends that are), take it from the vets that have actually been over there fighting in Iraq. They know how messed up it is. Take it from vets like Brian McGough. Check out VoteVets.org if you really care about the troops. In 2003, our own troops weren't properly equipped, but all of our private contractors had everything they needed. That's disgusting.

If all you watch is Fox News, and believe everything the White House Press Secretary says then yes I understand both of your positions, and we might as well stop now because it's hopeless. Just bury your head in the sand, and wave the GOP flag.

"First they came for the Communists, and I didn’t speak up, because I wasn’t a Communist. Then they came for the Jews, and I didn’t speak up, because I wasn’t a Jew. Then they came for the Catholics, and I didn’t speak up, because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me, and by that time there was no one left to speak up for me."

- Rev. Martin Niemoller, 1945

The League said...

Unfortunately, anonymous, I doubt any link or evidence I might point to, you would consider to be nothing but a fabrication of the liberal media. Either you believe whatever the White House and the media supporting the White House says, or you do occasionally believe someone whose paycheck doesn't require them to support George Bush and somehow missed the news the past few years.

I don't know if you're looking for directions on how to do a Google search (try "US+torture+rendition", just for fun), or what.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/03/04/60minutes/main678155.shtml

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Abu_Ghraib_53.jpg

http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/10/04/justice.torture.memos/index.html

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/04/28/60minutes/main691602.shtml


As per absolving the President of the behavior of soldiers who behave on their own or under orders: Our president is also commander in chief of the military, and therefore responsible for what the military does. This does not include just George Bush, but any and all presidents.

I am sure that by reading these and the countless other articles out there, you will be swayed. you've come off as a well reasoned and thoughtful person up to this point.

Anonymous said...

To Shadow:
The firing of 8 U.S. Attorneys had nothing to do with interrogation techniques. Neither did the resignation of Alberto Gonzales. The firings came because the 8 Attorneys were less than vigorous in pursuing voter fraud cases when the elections favored Democrats (one example is the Gubernatorial election in Washinton). In March 1993, President Clinton fired 93 U.S. Attorneys in one fell swoop. This had never been done in history. Of course, he appointed "Friend Of Bill" Paula Casey to be the U.S. Attourney from Little Rock, who never brought any Whitewater indictments. Were you outraged? Did you even know it happened back then? I certainly didn't.

The President cares deeply for the troops and he is very well liked by them. Retention rates are the highest they have ever been. In fact, the Army, Navy, and Air Force are paying people to get out, because too many people want to stay. The retention rates are highest among those who have served in Iraq and Afghanistan and they overwhelmingly request to go back when they complete their tours. Votevets.org does not speak for the vets, only for the Democrats. You should talk to the folks on the ground in Iraq and Afghanistan, not political ation committees.

To The League:
I am aware of Abu Ghraib. It was a tragedy. It was not U.S. policy, there were no orders for such behavior, and the people responsible have been held to account. Fortunately, the prisoners who were subject to the incident are alive and doing well. As you suggested, I Googled "U.S. Torture." It seems some people have applied the word "torture" to interrogation techniques that have existed for a long time. That may or may not be appropriate. Certainly President Bush has not outlawed these techniques, but neither had any previous President.

J.S. said...

To be fair, Bush not only didn't outlaw previously used techniques, but he also condoned a bunch of new techniques that hadn't been used before (The Justice Department, under the direction of newly appointed Alberto Gonzales, in 2005 issued a secret opinion allowing the use of some of the harshest interrogation techniques ever used- including physical assault, exposure to extreme tempreatures, simulated drowning, etc. This opinion was issued over the objection of deputy attorney general James Comey, who was in the process of resigning after having some difficult confrontations with The White House over exactly these kinds of issues). In July of 2006, the president signed an executive order (the details of which still remain secret) authorizing the use of what the administration calls "enhanced" interrogation techniques, especially for use in CIA "black sites" overseas. While I'm not exactly sure what "enhanced" interrgoation techniques are, given the fact that The White House feels the need to keep them secret and that they're pretty much only comfortable implementing them in secret overseas locations where no one can see what we're up to, I'm willing to bet my last cent that they're not at all pleasant. Bush is NOT just carrying on in the traditon of former presidents.

The League said...

http://www.wsws.org/articles/2004/jun2004/tort-j17.shtml

thevike13 said...

First off, don't even talk to me about elections. Florida in 2000 (thanks Florida republicans) or Ohio in 2004. Don't even start.

Second off, I was outraged at what clinton did during whitewater. yes. I do remember that. Clinton was a really crooked politician (just like Bush). That's the difference between you and I. I see crooked politicians. You see crooked democrats. You didn't read any of my last post did you? I haven't trusted the government since I was old enough to think for myself. I don't just step in line with whatever my government or political party tells me. I have no political party affliation because I hate both of them. Of course, I thought we were talking about this administration and what is happening now, not what happened 14 years ago. But I'm forgetting another classic Republican rebuttal: it's Clinton's fault. In fact, I think when Bush was owner of the Texas Rangers, he stated that the reason they sucked was because of Clinton.

I guess I can talk about how the Reagan administration supplied weapons to Saddam. I can talk about Rumsfeld meeting Saddam personally and helping broker the deal. I can talk about the cia selling drugs to buy weapons to help an insurgency in latin america. Everyone knows the cia has the best drugs. I can talk about the fact that the bin Laden family was the only flight allowed to leave on 9/11.

Were you outraged at the amount of your tax dollars that eventually led to the evidence that clinton got a bj from an intern? Or the shenigans and wasted tax dollars of an impeachment.

Furthermore, how dare you. The folks that started VoteVets.org were on the ground in Iraq and Afghanistan. That's why I pointed you to it. I say the same thing back to you: talk to these folks (who were on the ground) and not political action commitees.

You're going to believe a bunch of swift boat vets who were just a bunch of staunch republicans and now you're going to throw these vets, who served our country admirably under the bus? It's funny how you support a man that was an awol national guardsmen. A man that has failed in everything he has done including baseball. Everything he has done in his life was given to him by his old man.
Every failure was cleared up by his old man. You know what my response will be to you in further dialogues since this is the standard republican response "liberal media bias and lies":

radical, right wing, conservative bias and lies.

I love it. That's really the best rebuttal because you don't have to provide any evidence. You just say: liberal bias and lies and that's it. Everything is zippidy do dah. Bluebirds flying all around. In all of your posts here, you have not provided me any evidence to anything you are saying. The reason is because you know your sources are biased and in the back pocket of the republican party. Keep drinking the kool aid.

Show me your source for your statement that the military has the highest retention rates ever. Show me your source that states that the military has been trying to pay people to get out. If that is the case, why do I see ads constantly on tv, asking me to join the military. If the military is trying to pay people to get out, then why are they wasting money running ads across the country trying to get people to enlist?

Oh, I know what it is. It's the liberal media that is actually paying for these ads. They're doing it to discredit the president and gain political power. I can't believe I didn't think of that until now.

You're right though. It's clear that any site or source that does not back bush is all fabricated, liberal lies.

Despite presenting me with no evidence and rebutting very little of my points in my previous posts you have convinced me. dubya is the best president this country has ever had. I think we should take washington off of the dollar bill and put bush on it. he deserves it. look at all of the great things he has done during his two terms. everything he has done has been outstanding. he captured the people that were responsible for 911, he rebuilt new orleans, he has fought tooth and nail for protecting the planet and the environment, he has stopped war profiteering, brought peace and freedom to the Middle East, he has raised our standing and reputation in the world as being a world leader in truth and justice, he has provided health insurance to all of the american children and it's full time working citizens, he led our troops to victory in Iraq (the war is over right, he told us that major military operations ended years ago when he stood on the aircraft carrier), he has stopped the evil homosexuals from getting the same rights as every citizen, he has led this country into an unparalleled age of economic growth and increased wealth for all americans, the government has an enormous budget surplus (amazingly he did this by being the first president not to raise taxes during a time of war), he has an administration that is spotless with no corruption. furthermore, his administration didn't leak the name of a cia agent during a time of war. it wasn't treason, it was all just tricks by the liberal media.

he is the first president to not increase the size of the military in a time of war because of his great decision to pay private contractors.

he is a smart, intelligent, compassionate man who looks out for every poor person in not just this country, but the entire world. he supports disenfranchised people around the globe, and has made science a cornerstone of his administration. his administration is not bought and sold like most of our politicians and he answers to no one (not even the vice president). i think the best thing about the president though is steadfast commitment to following the ways of Jesus Christ: spreading love, and tolerance for all god's creatures, turning the other cheek, the meek inheriting the earth, etc.

i finally see. thank you for showing me the light. i had no idea that i was being controlled by liberals. i think we should stop fighting the terrorists, and just kill all liberals starting with hillary. because liberals aren't real americans. they're anti-americans, and they should leave our country. all they do is spread lies and promote america as being evil. Until the last election, the republicans had the majority in every branch of government, but i know you're right the liberal minority can be blamed for everything.

thank you so much for showing me the light. i feel embarrassed and ashamed for what i have said about this administration.

Finally, I suggest to you like I suggest to all staunch republicans, if you really want to show your support, put your money where your mouth is, and enlist. Help with Iraqi freedom. Quit your job, and enlist to support the greatest American president. In fact, the greatest leader of all time.

Thank you so much for your comments. Somehow I have been swayed despite seeing no evidence and no sources.

Anonymous said...

My friend Shadow,

I see. You are upset because President Bush doesn't believe the role of government is to conduct science experiments, provide universal health care, or redefine marriage. I am sure the list goes on.

So, you call him an idiot, spoiled, AWOL, etc. These terms don't help, especially AWOL, since it is factually incorrect. The others are your opinion, but they still don't help.

Military retention rates are not hard to find. I'm sure you can Google them yourself if you really want the truth.

How dare I speak poorly about votevets.org? This is exactly the reason they votevets formed...to allow the Bush haters to silence folks like me. "You haven't been there, you don't have a say." I don't need to hide behind their bravery to speak on the subject of war.

I believed President Clinton when he said lots of things. Unfortunately, I was proven wrong. I have not seen dishonesty from President Bush, but maybe I'll be proven wrong again.

Please, let's keep this dialoge going. Don't be upset.

J.S. said...

No dishonesty from President Bush? How about, just as a starting point, the assertion that we knew that there were weapons of mass destruction in Iraq? Here'a list to a web site which has documented and carefully chronicled a number of other Bush lies.

http://www.bushlies.net/

J.S. said...

Here's another web site that tracks and catalogs Bush's lies.

http://www.bushwatch.com/bushlies.htm

Honestly, you really have to bury your head in the sand to think that Bush has been straight with us.

J.S. said...

And, Anonymous, here are some accounts of some "extreme interrogations" of prisoners as recounted by American troops who were present in Iraq and Afghanistan at the time that these acts were committed (physical assaults, extreme temperatures, food and water deprivation, etc.).

http://hrw.org/reports/2006/us0706/

You may discount these stories as more liberal propaganda, but I'm not sure what's going to convince you this stuff is going on other than to put you in the room where the interrogations are taking place. Generally, people who might inflict torture aren't going to set up TV cameras or document their actions before they engage in it....

Anonymous said...

Steanso:
We knew there were no WMD? Interesting. There are 300,000 dead Shiites and 200,000 dead Kurds who would disagree, since they were killed by WMD delivered by Saddam's aircraft. Maybe you don't recall, but that's why we established a no-fly zone in the north and south. The only question is where they might be now. We might consider Iran and Syria, since that's where he sent his aircraft and tanks. Considering Saddam's use of chemical weapons and and refusal to demonstrate their destruction, Bill, Hillary, Kennedy, and Kerry had to assume Saddam still had them. Bush did the same. Certainly, none of them lied about WMD, but if you say it enough, people might start believing the nonsense.

Interrogation techniques are not torture. The individuals conducting the techniques have all been subject to them and a medical doctor is present to ensure safety. Certainly the enemies of this country would like to call them torture, because it helps their cause to defeat America. Certainly the Democrats would like to call them torture, because it helps their cause to defeat the Republicans. You can see why the comments of Bin Laden and Kerry sound so similar. This is unfortunate when troops are in the line of fire. Fortunately, they reenlist in huge numbers, because they see the progress and believe surrender in the midst of victory would be ridiculous.

Anonymous said...

The Miami Herold and USA Today did investigations into the 2000 election in Florida. Both said further recounts would have only increased President Bush's margin of victory.

The issue was that the traditional media called the election too early. The military heavy panhandle, the most Republican part of the state, still had its polls open. One news station sacrificed ratings to allow those in uniform to vote before calling the election. They were the only ones that got it right.

J.S. said...

The White House told the country that they had solid intelligence regarding WMDs in Iraq when in fact they knew and had been warned that their intelligence was false. Their most prominent informant, an individual codenamed Curveball, was a prisoner in German custoday, and the German government repeatedly tried to warn the U.S. that his "information" was highly suspect and very likely untrue.

http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/1121/dailyUpdate.html

Hans Blix, a man who had spent years in Iraq looking for WMDs as part of the UN's weapons inspection program, stated in a BBC interview in 2004 that he had repeatedly warned the U.S. government prior to the war that they were overstating the likelihood of WMDs being located in Iraq. His warnings were brushed aside and consciously ignored, despite that fact that Blix was the foremost expert in the world at the time regarding the likelihood of WMDs in Iraq.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Blix

This administration shoves aside and ignores anyone who provides them with knowledge that doesn't fit into their political agenda, and then they mislead the public with false justifications for their actions.

J.S. said...

And I bet that "interrogation techniques" sure feel like torture when you're stripped naked in the middle of the night, drenched in water, and are being kicked in the genitals by Americans (acts which have been recounted by American troops as having been performed on Iraqis).

http://hrw.org/reports/2006/us0706/

What you are employing here is what us lawyers call a "semantic dodge". Trying to avoid an issue by just trying to rename it doesn't make the underlying act any less morally abhorrent.

Anonymous said...

There were lots of people providing lots of different information. The dems, the UN, etc. all concurred that Saddam had WMD. Of course, France, China, and Russia (three countries with veto power on the UN Security Council) had been bribed and coerced by Saddam's Oil for Food program. Plus, there were 500,000 dead Iraqis to prove it.

Interrogation techniques are not supposed to be comfortable. They are not immoral. More immoral would be to disregard prisoners as a source of life saving information.

J.S. said...

Look, not only is torture or "extreme interrogation" immoral- it also produces false intelligence. In my experience just working at the courthouse I've seen suspects give false confessions to capital murder charges after a number of hours of being interrogated by the police (later exhonerated through DNA testing). If extended police interrogation at the station house is producing false information, I can just imagine what kind of intelligence we're gathering through waterboarding prisoners in Iraq.
In addition to that, we've now put "extreme interrogation" techniques on the table as being acceptable fopr use by the wordl community. Colin Powell and John McCain (leaders who've actually been in combat) are against any expansion of "extreme interrogation" techniques because they know that when America uses them, these actions make it more likely that those same techniques will be used against our own troops when they're captured (and we really won't have any moral right to complain about it).

As for our administration intentionally relying upon false information to justify the Iraq invasion, I don't know what to tell you- it's been reported over and over again by people who worked with and within the administration at that time that the White House misled the American public about their supposed "evidence" for the invasion of Iraq, but if you feel like burying your head in the sand about that issue, then I guess it's not going to matter what source I provide you with in demonstrating their dishonesty. Nonetheless, here's a statement made by General Wesley Clark in which he states that the White House already had their mind made up about invading Iraq, long before they even bothered to try to fabricate evidence to justify the invasion.

http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=1842

When leaders of other countries do things like that (mislead the public with erroneous evidence in order to justify an invasion) you hear words like "war criminal" being passed around.

Anonymous said...

I saw a great story today. Amputees are overwhelmingly volunteering to go back to Iraq and the DoD is now permitting their request. It is interesting that there are more amputees who want to go back to Iraq than who want to join votevets.org. This is not good for the anti-war movement which needs "victims" to promote its agenda.

Regarding interrogations: have you considered that the word torture might be a "semantic dodge," since interrogations involving water, sleep deprivation and other psychological techniques have existed for a long time and this word was never applied.

No one who fights for this country expects Islamic terrorists to use interrogation techniques to get information. Brutality and publicity is their objective, not information. We are quite different.

Regarding Shadow's Blackwater comments:
Blackwater will leave when the world's newest democracy (that's Iraq) determines that it is appropriate.

J.S. said...

Those amputees might have reasons other than buying into conservative rhetoric for going back inbto military service (I have a friend who got back from Iraq a number of months ago after his Humvee was hit with an IED- he has nothing but disdain for Bush and his policies, but he wants to go back to Iraq because he feels guilty about leaving his friends behind). Others may go back because they share your views. While I commend their service, it doesn't necessarily make their viewpoint the correct one.

As for torture and semantics- what are you going to call physical assault, near drowning, etc. when they start inflicting these thigs on our troops? Whether you call it torture or not, I bet you won't be too happy about it. And you really believe our enemies aren't going to try to extract intelligence from our troops when they're captured? What?!?! Simply saying we're different from our enemies doesn't make it so. We have to prove it through our actions.

Anonymous said...

I agree, their service doesn't necessarily make their viewpoint the correct one. That was my point when discussing votevets.org with Shadow.

I would be willing to oppose interrogation techniques to maintain America's good standing in the world, even though many say they are effective in providing information. Unfortunately, the reckless use of the word "torture" has already done international damage. If the debate is framed in terms of torture or not torture, I cannot take the "not torture" side, because I don't believe interrogation techniques are torture. If someone like me were to take the "not torture" position, it forces me to acknowledge that my country tortures. In addition to not believing this is true, it tarnishes my country's international image and I will not do that. If the debate is framed in terms of interrogation techniques, I could easily decide that some techniques are inappropriate.

If the objective was to protect prisoners, the debate would be framed in a manner that would be effective in moving in the direction of civil liberties. Instead, the debate is framed in an extreme way to discredit the President and our country.

J.S. said...

I'm sorry you feel that people's opposition to "extreme interrogation techniques" stems only from a desire to besmirch our president and our country. While obviously I'm not a big fan of George W. Bush, let me assure you that my opposition to these acts (call it torture or whatever) stems from a true concern regarding human rights, the welfare of our soldiers, and America's moral leadership in the world community. If Clinton or anyone else were trying to expand our nation's use of these techniques, I would be equally opposed to their policies, without regard for party allegiance. I am a dues paying member of Amnesty International and a member of the ACLU as well, and these organizations stand to safeguard against human and civil rights violations, regardless of which party is committing the infractions. This issue is too important to me to be used as just a tool for slinging mud at George Bush, and believe me when I say that I would stand up to criticize a Democrat president just as quickly if I thought that he were advocating policies that I deemed harmful to our country. (as a matter of fact, I'm still pretty pissed off at Hillary and John Kerry for just jumping on the band wagon and voting for the Iraq War)

Anonymous said...

Great to hear it.

thevike13 said...

"Regarding Shadow's Blackwater comments:
Blackwater will leave when the world's newest democracy (that's Iraq) determines that it is appropriate."

Ha ha ha. Your statement actually made me laugh. Do you really think Iraq has any choice in when Blackwater leaves? Wow. You definitely get your news from limited sources or you're more naive than I thought.

Blackwater will leave when this administration wants them to. Let's not kid ourselves. Iraq's puppet government, I mean the world's newest democracy, will make NO decisions regarding our troops, pullout, or the larger number of private contractors and their pullout. I don't care how many innocent civilians Blackwater kills. They will stay there until the Bush administration tells them to leave.

Iraq's goverment has been trying to kick out Blackwater for months.

Anonymous said...

Iraq's government was elected by the people of Iraq. 80% of them went to the polls under threat of death from insurgents and terrorists. This democracy can withdraw Blackwater's license to operate at any time. This new democracy has also requested time and again that American troops stay. Again, using words like "puppet government" doesn't help anyone. If you truely want American troops to leave you should support Iraq's new democracy and their efforts to secure themselves.

thevike13 said...

I want Blackwater to leave as does the Iraqi government. They have already revoked their license to operate in Iraq and have ordered them out of Iraq in the next six months.

You may find this surprising, but I don't think pulling our troops out of Iraq right now would be a wise idea. However, I think pulling every private contractor out of Iraq would be wise. These are mercenaries, plain and simple, who operate outside of the law.

The Afghanistan government announced today that they shut down two private security firms, and are planning on shutting down 10 more including some Western companies for lack of accountability, intimidation of citizens, disrespect of local security forces, inability to cooperate with authorities, and a few are suspected of murder and robbery.

If you are ok with the ethics and actions of these private security companies then at the very least, as a republican, aren't you apalled at our big government for paying Blackwater over $830 million since 2004 to protect our government officials? Our government pays each Blackwater contractor about $1200 a day. That's more than 6 to 9 times the pay and allowances of an Army sergeant. How is that saving us money. That's big, bureaucratic government at it's very best.

thevike13 said...

Also, maybe puppet government is a little too harsh. Maybe. All I know is they have no real control over their destiny. Our government will ultimately decide if and when our troops, and private military contractors leave. Now in regards to the private military contractors, our government may have no choice but to honor the Iraqi government's revocation of Blackwater's license to operate because of the PR mess that has developed.

I would be shocked if we don't establish a permanent base and constant military presence in Iraq. We usually leave permanent military bases behind in countries where we fight wars. Only time will tell, but history is definitely on my side. Our government isn't even giving the Iraqi government all of their oil.