I know I said I didn't have much to blog about today, but George W. found a way to piss me off enough to get me writing again. Today Bush vetoed a $35 billion expansion of the State Children's Health Insurance Program, stating that it provided healthcare for too many Americans who don't need it. This annoys me for a number of reasons. First off, the program is supposed to be funded through an increase in federal taxes on cigarettes, meaning that there wouldn't even be an increase in the federal income tax in order to fun this program (and people could just avoid paying the tax by not smoking- something that people shouldn't really be doing, anyway). Of course, the tobacco lobby is so far up Bush's - uh- rear end, that Bush would rather go to the mat and refuse to give insurance to American children rather than risk offending the tobacco industry. Second of all, who are these kids who don't need government health insurance? If there were any justice in the world, every child in America would receive free healthcare coverage. The SCHIP program is designed to help provide services to kids in families who have too much money to qualify for Medicaid, but who still can't afford to pay for private health insurance. The whole thing involves a matter of priorities- the president is willing to spend $700 billion for a pointless war in Iraq and give $50 billion in subsidies to oil companies, but he's worried about families somehow scamming the government by seeking healthcare for their children? Even if the wealthiest families in the country were getting free healthcare for their children, is universal healthcare coverage for children really something that's a bad thing? (especially when it's being paid for by taxing a vice that's killing tons of americans every year?) Jeez....
I gotta run, but it gets me mad.
9 comments:
SCHIP is a precursor to nationalized hillary care or more commonly referred to as socialism at it s best (actually worst). Once you don't pay for anything, you then demand unlimited services which liberal politicians and our litigious society will support. It is no longer the individual’s right to determine their level of service but will be left to politicians such as socialist hillary to determine who will get the medical care. Oh, you smoke; then we can't provide hospital care because you are going to die anyway. Why do you think you should judge anyone that chooses to smoke. You mean you eat at McDonalds and don't exercise, then we can't fix your clogged arteries...we have more deserving that need the limited service. Or worse yet, you must wait 6 months for emergency appendectomy ala Canada. Jason, we need more individual responsibility for healthcare not more politicians pandering for votes which is all this legislation is doing. Paraphrasing the White House, why require free anything to anyone making $80,000 per year and then require lower income individuals to pay for it with a regressive tabaco tax. It doesn't make sense. See the attached article for ideas. http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2007/10/control_your_own_health_care.html
Oh, jeez. You're still here?
Look, I'm not doing the whole point by point political debate thing here. Suffice it to say that I've heard your talking points before and found them unpersuasive (e.g., the whole "any tiny aspect of socialized medicine will immediately reduce the quality of the system" argument, the argument that a few people potentially abusing the benefits of a health care system means that we should throw out the whole system, and I especially like the big-tobacco lawyer argument comparing McDonald's to cigarettes [while I'll admit that those Big Macs are tasty, until you find one that's been chemically engineered to make people eat more of them, I think I'll continue to find that comparison unconvincing]).
I don't know if you're new to the site or what, but I'm fine with being called a liberal (think they've done some pretty good things over the years), I don't think all socialism is a bad idea, and I may very well end up voting for Hillary for president.
I'm tired.
wow. i didn't realize it. first, socialized health care then
communism then the end of the world as we know it.
and to think i was scared of the corruption in our white house and the undermining of our regular military troops by private contractors. Private contractors who answer to know one, make millions, hire thugs and mercenaries from
other countries who used to work for dictators so they can go around
shooting civilians. the destruction of our constitution and the bill of rights.
what i also didn't realize was that only poor people smoked cigarettes
and tobacco products. we can't have any regressive taxes because
that's really who the white house is working for: the poor. the tobacco lobby had nothing to gain from blocking legislation that would have added additional taxes to tobacco products. that makes sense.
those poor canadians. if they have to wait six months for an emergency
appendectomy, could you give me the number of canadians that have died
because of the delay? i'm no doctor, but i was under the impression that if you needed an emergency appendectomy, you would have to get it asap or you risk death. so please give me the canadian death rates from untreated appendicitis because of their evil socialist health care system.
i need to check out realclearpolitics so i can learn how spending 700 billion in Iraq has helped us track down bin Laden and al Queda. how winning hearts and minds involves private contractors shooting Iraqi civilians and then paying their families $5k a person for murdering their family members.
love the fetus, hate the child. that's the new catchphrase at the white house.
you recommend realclearpolitics, i recommend you read 1984.
Okay, SOMEONE has gotta take the obvious next step and grab themselves the screen name of Da Jester, post haste.
By the way, even Kay Bailey "I worship at the feet of Dubbya" Hutchison was in favor of an expansion of the SCHIP program and against the president's veto. When even a party line Republican shock trooper like Hutchison is breaking ranks, you might think Bush would reconsider whether his evilness had gotten a little out of hand this time.
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/region/legislature/stories/10/04/1004schiptexas.html
Socialized healthcare seems like a big scary thing. And then you actually get sick and need help.
If not for Medicare, my wife would currently be dead. The cost of dialysis would bankrupt virtually any American within a few months.
My wife did not become ill because she did not take care of herself. She was struck with a sclerosis of the kidney at the age of 17. I assure you, she is not the only person at her clinic with a similar story.
However, I sincerely doubt most Americans would continue to support politicians or a plan that would refuse to provide assistance in the manner you suggest. You have far more to fear from insurance companies worrying about who they will and will not ensure and for what than you do the government telling voters they can't receive medical help. (Someday review what your insurance carrier finds to be "experimental treatment", and who they are willing to ensure and at what rates if your office weren't in the position to bargain for you).
The government doesn't have a bottom line and stock holders to make rich.
As per insuring children: Spend a night in the ER sometime and see how the uninsured are currently caring for their children. The ER's are currently filled with children who the ER must treat without insurance and who will probably not pay, rather than being able to go to regular doctors offices due to a lack of insurance (what's the first question they asks when you call to schedule an appointment with your Internal Medicine doctor?).
Consequently, receiving care at the ER takes hours for even those suffering from broken bones, etc... as the kids with colds get sorted out.
Like it or not, you're paying that emergency room bill if you choose to use the hospital, helping to cover their costs, which run several hundred dollars just to get looked at (I had my foot X-Rayed in 2002 to the tune of $973. And was misdiagnosed.).
You're already participating in low-level socialized medicine. You're just mistaken in your belief that when you pay your hospital bills, you're only paying for yourself.
By the way, here's what Factcheck.org ( a nonpartisan political fact checking organization) had to say about the president's argument for vetoing an expansion of the SCHIP program:
http://www.factcheck.org/bushs_false_claims_about_childrens_health_insurance.html
Unsurpsingly, the president misrepresented which children the program would benefit as well was the overall effect that the expansion would have in terms of moving us toward a socialized health care system.
The president
Post a Comment