Hey. Well, it's Friday.
I spent a good portion of my evening last night trying to work on some songs that I've been trying to write. I go through long periods when I don't pick up my guitar much at all outside of band practice, and then sometimes I go through periods when I spend quite a bit of time playing music at night. I record occasional tunes that I come up with on my cheap little tape player, and I scribble down lyrics on leftover legal pads, and most of it never sees the light of day (I tend to mostly chicken out when it comes to actually sharing my stuff with other people, although I recorded a few songs to CD a while back and we took to playing them with the band). Still, I enjoy the process, and I hang onto some of my songs and play them over and over (I have some that are from way back in high school that I play on occasion because I just like the tunes). I have a hard time writing songs, and I tend to rework them a lot of times before I'm even marginally comfortable with them. I've always been amazed and impressed by Eric (our bandleader with the Mono E). He seems to have a much more natural ability to just kind of channel some sort of creative energy, seemingly effortlessly producing lyrics and melodies (he very well might say that the process really isn't all that effortless, but he makes it seem like it comes easily to him, and he's both fairly prolific and produces really good stuff). Anyway, expressing himself through music seems to come more naturally to Eric than it does to me (or to probably 99% of the people out there). I feel like I'm sweating a lot more to produce a small fraction of the material with my end results often being of questionable quality. Oh well. I still enjoy it.
Al Gore was awarded a Nobel Prize today for his work on curbing greenhouse gas emissions and fighting global warming. I know that this award is going to make a lot of American conservatives groan (they'll undoubtedly see it as yet another example of those European liberals trying to place ambitious American industrialism under siege), but I think that this award just goes to show how seriously the rest of the world is taking the problem of global warming while Americans sit back and debate whether the problem even exists (or whether human action has had anything to do with causing global warming and whether it's worth our time to try to take action that might reduce its effects). You gotta love America. We'll probably still be arguing about whether or not we should do something about global warming once Manhatten is flooded under a foot or two of water.
Gotta run. Hope you guys are having a good Friday.
12 comments:
....and Al Gore created the internet....what a guy! ...and Al Gore and Michael Moore got a grummy or whatever for docufiction. I wonder why British schools were going to require Al Gore indoctrination until their legal system indicated that the science is not all settled and Al Gore is factually incorrect in some of his conclusions. Thus, it is not just the US that has a problem with Al Gore. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml;jsessionid=BYVTNMH40LUKZQFIQMGSFFWAVCBQWIV0?xml=/opinion/2007/10/12/do1202.xml
Jason, while I think global warming is being observed, it is quite another leap to conclusively state it is all manmade and the US is the bad guy as most liberals want us to believe. Many scientists are suggesting global warming is part of the normal cycle and we are a very small part of the contribution. There are other theories to explain the phenomena such a sun spots and normal solar system fluctuation similar to our 4 seasons. This kind of makes sense since we have had several ice ages and warm periods which did not include manmade carbon emissions. Oh, did Al Gore note the polar ice caps are shrinking…on MARS! This is an inconvenient fact missing from his observations since he couldn’t explain how my SUV made it melt. The snows of Kilimanjaro are melting due to carbon emissions…another fiction the British observed. I believe he even blamed Katrina to this issue….again not true per the British. The liberal media and the extreme left wing moveon.org crowd will no doubt grand stand this buffoons factual errors as somehow worthy of a Nobel “Peace” prize. Eventually, no matter how you slice it, science will trump his left wing political agenda.
Sounds like you have a political agenda of your own. If even a small part of global warming is man made (and I truly believe that the overwhelming majority of credible science out there indicates that human activity has actually had a much more than minimal impact, with most of the contrary evidence being junk science that's been drummed up by energy companies or other organizations who have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo), than I think we still owe it to the human race to do everything that we can to curb greenhouse emissions. No one ever said that the entire process of global warming is man made (or maybe someone said that, but for the sake of argument, let's assume that humans have only contriubted to the problem instead of being its sole cause), but if humans are harming the climate in a way that even makes the earth SOMEWHAT more susceptible to solar fluctuations than we would otherwise be, than we're still responsible for contributing to global warming- albeit by destroying the atmosphere that's supposed to protect us and not by completely generating the global warming phenomenon itself. Personally, I think science will trump the conservative/libertarian political agenda. I just hope that we don't all have to wait upon catastrophic climate consequences in order to settle the debate.
(the counterarguments in this case just smell a lot like the "scientific evidence" produced by laboratories working in the employ of the cigarette companies from the 60's through the 90's who kept producing studies for decades that supposedly showed that cigarettes weren't addictive and had no links whatsoever to causing cancer. Ultimately their research was shown to be horribly, if not intentionally, flawed, but not before hundreds of thousands of more people got cancer)
By the way, your link is to the online version of The Daily Telegraph, a conservative British newspaper that makes Fox News look like it's for hippies. You'll forgive me if I don't take the opinions expressed therein as carrying more credibility than opinions of the Nobel Prize nominations committee.
The bottom line is that the pollutants which are thought to create global warming are known to not be very good for people, anyway. It's kind of silly to suggest that pumping carcinogens into the atmosphere is a great idea for anyone but the companies who don't want to pay for their carbon footprint.
Whether you believe the vast, vast majority of scientists who support the pollutants as culprits of global warming or not, its worth looking 100 years down the road to foresee all of the potential hazards of allowing pollutants to be emitted unchecked.
And, btw, Al Gore claimed credit for his work in Congress to create the internet. Which, reviewing at his actions, is accurate.
"But it will emerge from my dialogue with the American people. I've traveled to every part of this country during the last six years. During my service in the United States Congress, I took the initiative in creating the Internet. I took the initiative in moving forward a whole range of initiatives that have proven to be important to our country's economic growth and environmental protection, improvements in our educational system."
Ok, so the moveon.org crowd believes Al Gore is a scientist and not a politician with a, “… I know what’s best for you.” attitude and the facts in a news article are not facts unless they are presented in a left wing news format. So let’s do as suggested and fix the manmade problem. Why not take the “bull by the horns” so to speak and really correct the manmade problem rather than try to get me out of my SUV which isn’t a big enough solution. Per the LA Times article (hopefully left wing enough) you & I need to give up meat to reduce our carbon footprint. Hey, we can even get the government to ban meat, force us to lose some pounds, get healthier and not be a burden on our socialized hillarycare system…no more McDonalds and we create a smaller carbon footprint for Al Gore…global warning solved.
It’s a bit long but here is an excerpt:
Livestock are a leading source of greenhouse gases. Why isn't anyone raising a stink?
October 15, 2007
It's a silent but deadly source of greenhouse gases that contributes more to global warming than the entire world transportation sector, yet politicians almost never discuss it, and environmental lobbyists and other green activist groups seem unaware of its existence.
That may be because it's tough to take cow flatulence seriously. But livestock emissions are no joke.
Most of the national debate about global warming centers on carbon dioxide, the world's most abundant greenhouse gas, and its major sources -- fossil fuels. Seldom mentioned is that cows and other ruminants, such as sheep and goats, are walking gas factories that take in fodder and put out methane and nitrous oxide, two greenhouse gases that are far more efficient at trapping heat than carbon dioxide. Methane, with 21 times the warming potential of CO2, comes from both ends of a cow, but mostly the front. Frat boys have nothing on bovines, as it's estimated that a single cow can belch out anywhere from 25 to 130 gallons of methane a day.
It isn't just the gas they pass that makes livestock troublesome. A report from the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization identified livestock as one of the two or three top contributors to the world's most serious environmental problems, including water pollution and species loss. In terms of climate change, livestock are a threat not only because of the gases coming from their stomachs and manure but because of deforestation, as land is cleared to make way for pastures, and the amount of energy needed to produce the crops that feed the animals.
All told, livestock are responsible for 18% of greenhouse-gas emissions worldwide, according to the U.N. -- more than all the planes, trains and automobiles on the planet. And it's going to get a lot worse. As living standards rise in the developing world, so does its fondness for meat and dairy. Annual per-capita meat consumption in developing countries doubled from 31 pounds in 1980 to 62 pounds in 2002, according to the Food and Agriculture Organization, which expects global meat production to more than double by 2050. That means the environmental damage of ranching would have to be cut in half just to keep emissions at their current, dangerous level.
It isn't enough to improve mileage standards or crack down on diesel truck emissions, as politicians at both the state and national levels are working to do….
Here is the complete article for your enjoyment….
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-ed-methane15oct15,0,1365993.story?coll=la-opinion-leftrail
The bottom line is beware of politicians that claim the science is settled when other scientists point out glaring errors in their thesis. History has demonstrated many times that scientific discovery is not a political vote where whoever lines up the most scientists must be right. You are much better off to think for yourself rather than be spoon fed by someone claiming to know best…especially someone like moveon.org. I understand the framers of the Constitution introduced the concept that politicians work for the people not that the people work for the government. Unfortunately, many liberal politicians including too many conservative politicians tend to forget this concept. Me thinks politicians like Hillary Clinton and Al Gore have never believed in this concept.
I think there are a lot more people supporting the notion of global warming than just moveon.org or Al Gore. 172 countries have ratified the Kyoto Protocols (an international treaty on climate change) on greenhouse gas emissions, with the U.S. and Australia being noticeably absent. This is kind of troubling since although the U.S. is by no means alone in contributing to the greenhouse gas problems we now face, by 2005 the U.S. had moved into positions as the single largest emitter of carbon dioxide (from the burning of fossil fuels) in the world.
As for the livestock/methane global warming thing, I really hadn't heard about it before, but I've done some cursory fact checking, and appoarently you're right about the whole livestock emissions thing being a real problem (in addition to the problems being created through overgrazing and deforestation for the sake of increased ranch land). I'm not sure why this issue doesn't get more attention, except, as you pointed out, that it's hard to take cow pollution seriously. I still don't think that this takes away the need to worry about fossil fuel emissions, but it's an interesting point and shows a different aspect of the whole global warming issue.
I think the answer is that a vast, vast majority of scientists buy into the theory you perceive as lefty rhetoric.
I'm not sure where to go with your argument that Al Gore is not a scientist (true enough), but that scientists are in disagreement regarding global warming. This isn't new science. It's had more than twenty years to be tested (I recall hearing about it in science in middle school and CFCs being removed from my Right Guard in 9th grade), and results are now being seen globally. Assuming that Gore doesn't know what he's talking about suggests that he hasn't spent considerable time investigating the topic seems a bit disingenuous, despite his degree. Further, it suggests that Gore somehow stands to profit by alarming the populace.
I think the question I ask myself is: What does Gore have to gain from an environmental mission? What do polluters have to gain from refuting his stance?
Even the Vatican has made steps toward becoming carbon neutral, joining up with the dozens and dozens of governments who have recognized the scientific evidence is overwhelming enough that its worth potentially slowing the economy. Or, in fact, admitting that mankind have been poor stewards of the Earth given to them by God.
As per the cattle: unless we get some serious genetic engineering going, we can't control either the gas from organic polluters such as cattleb. Further, with more people currently living on Earth than ever before by a few billion, it stands to reason that we need the cattle. Whether we are able to address cow farts is a topic I'm not sure science has yet been able to tackle.
What we can tackle are the emissions and pollutants we cause by the decisions we make personally, or as part of larger organizations. It may cost money and require oversight, but we currently know how to reduce wasteful emissions from factories, cars, etc... Further, we have technology in place to reduce the amount of fuel burned per mile, and have simply not put much R&D into that technology, nor have we done much to put the technology into place that we do have.
Further, by definition, no field in the sciences is a place where everything is agreed upon. That's antithetical to the process, and kind of the point of research. (Much like the urban myth regarding closing down the patent office in 1899, "Everything that can be invented has been invented.".) That's why, in my previous response, I suggested considering the carcinogen angle as a legitimate reason for reducing emissions.
Claiming "scientists disagree" is a fair and accurate statement, but also assumes that all scientists have the same research, degrees, goals, experience, etc... A quick Google Search says only half of scientists agree, while other articles state that 90% of climate researchers agree:
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/302204_warming02.html
Certainly the numbers seem to have changed in the past ten years if you look at the articles.
I don't follow MoveOn. While I do not see "liberal" as a dirty word, any more than I see "conservative" as a negative label, I'm a bit baffled by your insistence that I would only follow "liberal" publications and media. I don't consider programs like Nova to have much of a political angle, and I do read middle-conservative publications that recognize and interview scientists on this topic, as well as watching plenty of other news and science programming which discusses the issue.
Honestly, the first thing to make me suspicious of anyone's fact checking is when they insist that anyone who believes the other side has been duped. What I would ask is that you to consider what interests, political or otherwise, are being served by either side.
Steanso, you gotta ask yourself why the Republican Senate didn’t ratify the Kyoto Treaty….there has to be a very good reason. Maybe it is not in the interest of the US and someone doing their due diligence has determined that it would put the US in a serious disadvantage on a global basis. The facts about Kyoto Treaty is….it didn’t and doesn’t work except as a vehicle to bash the US. While I’m not sure of the details, I believe underdeveloped countries would not have any constraints….pretty easy to sign if a country thought there was an economic advantage over the bad US. Also, I believe China was excluded (or didn’t sign) from constraints or at least there were no penalty if they exceeded the Kyoto Protocol. Case in point, in 2003, China's carbon-dioxide emissions were 78 percent of the U.S. level. Developing countries, in total, accounted for 37 percent of greenhouse-gas emissions in 2003. By 2050, their share could be 55 percent, projects the International Energy Agency. Last year, the United Nations reported that of the 41 countries it monitors (not including most developing nations), 34 had increased greenhouse emissions from 2000 to 2004. These include most countries committed to reducing emissions under the Kyoto Protocol. Oh you mentioned the US was the biggest polluter in 2005….flash….China will surpass the US in 2007 primarily from coal-fired power plants and has no interest in curtailing their industrial development. Based on this track record, somehow explain to me how the Kyoto Treaty has worked in curtailing global warming. On the other hand, if we just make you a vegan, we would solve the problem….no more McDonalds for you.
You really need to listen to more Rush Limbaugh to offset the moveon.org filter. He was on top of the “cow” problem a long time ago when the liberal press was suppressing the story. Evidently, it is OK now to report since Al Gore got his awards. Just remember, all told, livestock are responsible for 18% of greenhouse-gas emissions worldwide, according to the U.N. -- more than all the planes, trains and automobiles on the planet. So fix the problem by skipping your “Whopper”! A more effective slogan than blame the US for not signing the Kyoto Protocol.
Steanso, you gotta ask yourself why the Republican Senate didn’t ratify the Kyoto Treaty….there has to be a very good reason. Maybe it is not in the interest of the US and someone doing their due diligence has determined that it would put the US in a serious disadvantage on a global basis. The facts about Kyoto Treaty is….it didn’t and doesn’t work except as a vehicle to bash the US. While I’m not sure of the details, I believe underdeveloped countries would not have any constraints….pretty easy to sign if a country thought there was an economic advantage over the bad US. Also, I believe China was excluded (or didn’t sign) from constraints or at least there were no penalty if they exceeded the Kyoto Protocol. Case in point, in 2003, China's carbon-dioxide emissions were 78 percent of the U.S. level. Developing countries, in total, accounted for 37 percent of greenhouse-gas emissions in 2003. By 2050, their share could be 55 percent, projects the International Energy Agency. Last year, the United Nations reported that of the 41 countries it monitors (not including most developing nations), 34 had increased greenhouse emissions from 2000 to 2004. These include most countries committed to reducing emissions under the Kyoto Protocol. Oh you mentioned the US was the biggest polluter in 2005….flash….China will surpass the US in 2007 primarily from coal-fired power plants and has no interest in curtailing their industrial development. Based on this track record, somehow explain to me how the Kyoto Treaty has worked in curtailing global warming. On the other hand, if we just make you a vegan, we would solve the problem….no more McDonalds for you.
You really need to listen to more Rush Limbaugh to offset the moveon.org filter. He was on top of the “cow” problem a long time ago when the liberal press was suppressing the story. Evidently, it is OK now to report since Al Gore got his awards. Just remember, all told, livestock are responsible for 18% of greenhouse-gas emissions worldwide, according to the U.N. -- more than all the planes, trains and automobiles on the planet. So fix the problem by skipping your “Whopper”! A more effective slogan than blame the US for not signing the Kyoto Protocol.
I wish I could bring myself to give up the cheeseburgers, believe me. It would be a good idea for a number of reasons. While it's true that China is on track to surpass the U.S. as an emissions gas producer, we're still number 2, and that ain't all that good (and given the fact that China has something like 4 times our population, we're still much worse polluters on a per capita basis). It's a common argument that other countries are just trying to handicap the U.S. economy or hold us back in other ways, but I think that in truth, they mostly just want the U.S. to sign the protocol because we're one of the world's biggest polluters. If you lived in a small town and there was one big house that produced a hugely disproportionate amount of the trash for your neighborhood, wouldn't you want to see the neighbors in that house step up and take responsibility for their actions? While it's also true that developing countries continue to increase their production of greenhouse gas emissions, they still aren't anywhere close to matching ours, and its going to be hard for us to argue that they need to get their pollution under control when we've refused to take responsibility for our own. I think that our Republican leaders are against signing the Kyoto Protocol primarily because they're getting pressure from the energy industry lobby (which supports those same leaders and puts campaign dollars in their pockets- an industry which is much more interested in keeping up their profitablility for the sake of their shareholders than they're interested in worrying about the global enviromental impact of their actions). We need to find increased ways of putting pressure on the energy industry in terms of getting them to clean up their act and finding alternative sources of fuel (besides coal and oil). Bush has given this concept a nod of approval, but we need more of a carrot and stick approach (subsidies for alternative energy sources and penalties and taxes for pollution).
OK, since you are the US, I want you to follow your own rational for the US and take responsibility for your own excess pollution as outlined in your good neighbor scenario. What’s good for the goose is good for the gander, so don’t hide behind the old adage, “do as I say, not as I do.” Unfortunately, you’re indentifying the problem as industry lobbying Congress when you are the chief polluter. After all, don’t ever forget that profits are good! Due to and because of the profit incentive, we have been the most innovative country in the world and have produced the luxuries that you and the rest of the world have become accustomed. Anywho, now that you realize the Big Mac is causing more pollution than your vehicle (as noted in the ‘cow’ article), it is time for you to voluntarily drive by that Whopper and become a devout vegan. After all, according to Al Gore, you will eliminate global warming and as discussed do it in a much faster way than controlling big business. Come on, you can do eeeit! If you feel so strongly that it is only the right thing for the US to do to prevent manmade global warming, I am sure you are willing to voluntarily change your eating habits. Or perhaps we can elect Hillary and she will mandate your eating habits to solve global warming. As a bonus, you will be healthier and we will be able to afford her brand of socialized hillarycare. On the other hand, if you don’t agree with this scenario, then you aren’t any different than the US not signing the Kyoto Protocol. Perhaps you are more conservative than you think. Or perhaps you will take another look at Al Gore, ‘the science is settled’ thesis and maybe think it is not worth the effort if it is based on junk science. In the end, I believe it will be the profit incentive that will create the innovation to solve the pollution without requiring you to give up your Big Mac. Let’s hope we aren’t too socialized by Hillary that it will get in the way of that happening.
I'm not sure looking at cattle as the culprit is as much of an issue as implementing emission reducing technology. The eating changes may be a necessary item to look at, bu there are more immediate changes which require the implementation of technology.
Many industries simply don't want to expend the capital necessary to manage their emissions because it does cut into the bottom line. And, yes, profits are good, but weighed against the alternative...?
This is why we're seeing so many ads from companies like BP who, on first blush, seems like polluters. These days, BP is pushing their solar work, their fuel-cell work, etc... on their commercials, so when you do pull up to a BP to fill up your tank, you're supposed to get a warm fuzzy. After all, your dollar spent on petroleum is funding R&D into tidal energy.
At some point, cattle will be a problem, but at this point, the argument feels like a distraction from the other 80% of polluters.
Yeah, I still don't believe that Al Gore's science is junk science, and while I agree that profit is typically a good thing, the capitalist system also has its weaknesses, and one of them may be that the market may not recognize the value of greener energy (thereby making it more profitable) fast enough to help remedy the enviromental hazards that we face. I think that over the long haul that greener energy sources will definitely become much more profitable. I'm just not sure that people will realize how important it is to switch over to those energy sources until after too much irreversible damage has already been done.
Also, I think the cow thing is interesting, but probably ultimately a distraction from the real problem which lies in fossil fuel emissions. Just because there are other contributing factors out there doesn't get the energy companies off the hook.
Post a Comment