So it's Friday. The 13th. Eric, the intrepid leader of the Mono Ensemble, and his wife, Stephanie, tend to have small social gatherings at their home when these allegedly ominous Fridays roll around, and I think tonight there may be some beer drinking and guitar strumming tonight, in keeping with the tradition.
There's an article in The New York Times today about how Bush keeps intentionally distorting his depictions of Al Qaeda in Iraq and the reasons why Al Qaeda is fighting us there. Bush has repeatedly referred to Al Qaeda in Iraq as one of the reasons we're at war over there, and implied that Al Qaeda is one of the reasons that we invaded Iraq in the first place. In truth, intelligence experts believe that Al Qaeda wasn't even in Iraq prior to our invasion, and that Al Qaeda fighters migrated there (or were recruited into the organization from the indigenous Iraqi population) in order to fight the U.S. once the war started. In yet another display of dishonesty, Bush has repeatedly implied that we invaded Iraq in order to go after Al Qaeda and that we can't leave Iraq because it's an Al Qaeda stronghold. The truth of the matter is that Saddam Hussein was not an ally of Al Qaeda and didn't tolerate its operation within his country. Al Qaeda popped up to fight us once the war broke out, but they probably would have migrated to almost any country in the region so long as there was a war going on to hide their immigration and a promising chance that they were going to get to take some cheap shots at American troops (i.e., if we had invaded France, I bet there would have been Al Qaeda IEDs and snipers sneaking into the country within weeks). It's true that Al Qaeda now has a significant presence in Iraq, but the irony is that the American invasion and accompanying destabilization of the country was the catalyst for Al Qaeda's infiltration of Iraq. If the president thinks we need to stay there now in order to get Al Qaeda out of Iraq, he ought to at least 'fess up to a "we broke it, we bought it" type philosophy.
Which brings me to my next point. I'm glad that our Democratic leaders have finally awoken to the folly of our decision in invading Iraq, but I'm a little concerned about their lack of any cohesive exit strategy in wanting to pull out of the region. Although it's often cited by conservatives as a reason for their infuriating "stay the course" philosophy regarding the Iraq war, I think there are very legitimate concerns about whether widespread genocide would occur if the U.S. were to suddenly pull all of its troops out of Iraq. Although we should have considered these issues before the invasion, the fact remains that the U.S. has destabilized the country through our own actions, and now I think we're responsible for attempting to secure some kind of safety for its citizens.
Of course, I still want to see our troops out of Iraq, so I think we need some kind of plan that both gets us out of there and prevents ethnic cleansing or other forms of genocide. The plan should probably incorporate the continuing effort to create an effective, stable Iraqi military and police force (under the command of a government which is committed to not only majority rule, but also the protection of groups in the minority), as well as some kind of plan by the U.S. military which withdraws our troops from the borders of Iraq, but which keeps U.S. troops readily available in Saudi Arabia or some other "standby region" so that we can implement quick strikes and military support missions to aid the Iraqis if help is called for by their government (a kind of "pull and strike" strategy*). In short, we need to get the Iraqis to stand on their own feet, but we need to be readily available if they have trouble. I'm not sure of the best way to accomplish this, but the Democrats need to start coming up with some plans before we just yank out our troops and let Iraq descend into chaos.
Anyway, I just don't want the U.S. blamed for Iraqi genocide in addition to all of the other problems that we've already created. I know that we need to extricate ourselves from Iraq, but we owe the Iraqi people the duty of making sure that they are at least as safe when we leave as they were when we invaded their country.
Okay. End of rant.
Hope everyone's doing okay today.
* I didn't come up with this "pull and strike" thing on my own. I've read versions of it a few places, including an op/ed piece in Newsweek by Jonathan Alter from 6/25/07
2 comments:
Well put. And, you have my vote - Steanso for president!!
TA
It just seem slike there's a whole lot of complaining going on with all of our politicians without many alternative strategies being offered. The Democrats are no better than the Republicans if they can't come up with some workable strategies of their own.
Post a Comment