Hey! Man, I got nothing today. Really.
There was kind of an interesting story today on the Fox News site about Marvel Comics generating some controversy. Apparently a recent issue of Captain America had some references to the Tea Party- comments which real members of the Tea Party movement found offensive. Among the controversial comments were some statements which implied that the movement was made up of mostly angry white people. That sort of a deal.
Knowing that Ryan (my brother and comic book enthusiast extaordinaire) is really more suited to comment on this sort of thing, I contacted him, and this is what he had to say on the matter:
"Well, the article basically demonstrates that (a) Fox news has no concept of the creation process of a comic (the writer doesn't draw the page or letter the page), and (b) they cannot believe a writer could separate his personal life from his professional output.
And given some of the signs one sees at a protest, I can only roll my eyes at Fox's protest.
Brubaker is a smart guy, and I doubt he'd be rushing to irritate a paying audience. But his characters are also not a blank slate of lantern-jawed heroism that most people generically asign to comic characters, and, as the article indicates, get offended by any suggestion that super heroes don't reflect cut and dried views for kids.
Part of the shift from comics-are-for-kids to serving an adult audience is that lead protagonist characters in comics often come packaged with a strong ideology, and many would be surprised to find superheroes come from across the spectrum. Falcon has been characterized as an educated guy from New York City, and so, yes, he might find mid-Western Tea Party protestors a bit amusing or hold certain opinions of those stereotypes. I'm not saying Falcon couldn't be written differently, but he came out of Jack Kirby's 1970's exploration of the social issues of the day (although ham-handed by today's standards).
Crying fowl that a character portrayed as a hero has a negative opinion of a movement that Fox supports, is, at the end of the day, baiting Marvel and a bit of propaganda on Fox's part. And if they need to worry, Iron Man, Marvel's resident super-neo-con, is far more popular than Red Falcon.
I think it should be noted: Cap comics have long been used as a "Stranger in a Strange Land", showing Steve Rogers, who is a product of America's 20th Century Golden Age (he was raised during the Depression and fought in WWII) dealing with the political complexities of an America he barely recognizes. Tea Party protests are just reflective of that ongoing undercurrent in the Cap books.
I'm just saying."
ADDENDUM: Ryan sent this link to a comic blog in which a guy named Joe tries to explain how this whole issue arose in the first place.
So maybe this counts as cheating, but I'm counting this as my post for today (remember when I started out saying I couldn't come up with anything?). As I predicted, Ryan had some pretty strong points on the whole Marvel Comics versus the Tea Party thing.
Peace, guys!
4 comments:
Your brother is a genius.
-your brother
I will be sure to pass that along to him. I'm sure he'll be happy to hear it.
This is why you shouldn't apologize to the Tea Party, even if you did screw up:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ynews/20100211/ts_ynews/ynews_ts1129
The movement is unable to not cast themselves as victims. They're rapidly becoming the right's answer to the irrepressible left-wing nut that the Dems have carried for 40 years.
A) Philips' read of Cap as anything other than a New Deal Democrat was incorrect
B) You don't have to apologize for re-using materials used by actual party members.
C) At some point, you need to identify the Tea-Party for the fear-mongering joke the movement all too rapidly became, and just stop apologizing. Any attention what-so-ever just feeds the internal propaganda.
Word.
Post a Comment