Monday, February 01, 2010

Bipartisanship and the Lion's Den

Hey! Kind of uneventful, but a pretty decent weekend. Joined Ryan, Jamie, Matt, Nicole, Julia, and Pat for dinner on Friday at Artz Ribhouse. The food was pretty good, but more importantly, it was just a good chance to hang out and catch up.
Saturday I had lunch did a little bit of shopping with Ryan and Jamie, and Saturday night I went to Maudie's with Ryan, Jamie, Matt, and Nicole. We had a good time, but man, that place gets crowded and noisy on a Saturday night.
Sunday I did a lot of bumming around, and had band practice in the evening. Well, actually, we were supposed to have band practice, but it fell apart. Reed and I played a little bit with just the two of us and just sort of hung out.
The weekend was also filled with a lot of Mass Effect 2. It's a really cool game, but it's long and complicated. I was trying to just sort of quickly show it to Reed last night, and I realized that although it has good graphics, the things that are really impressive about Mass Effect 2 aren't things that you can really show someone in 10 or 15 minutes. I mean, the graphics are good, but lots of games have some pretty impressive graphics these days. The things that are really impressive about Mass Effect 2 are things like how well the characters are developed, the complexity and richness of the storyline and the universe, the continuity that occurs between the first and second games, and so forth. You get to know characters and build a history and a sort of relationship with them in the game. Choices that you make help determine how other characters interact with you. As you help different people out and build alliances with them, you do favors for them and they return favors for you. So, although the artwork is pretty good, the storyline is probably actually the coolest thing about Mass Effect 2. But that's a hard thing to demonstrate to a friend by showing him the game for a few minutes before band practice. Instead, the game sort of rewards people who are willing to sit down and make the time commitment to play the thing through.
And the game can eat up a lot of your time. But it's fun.

I watched a good chunk of the video from President Obama's speech and question and answer session with Republicans on Friday. I had heard a great deal about this session (at a Republican retreat) before I actually saw any of it, with pundits and reporters talking about how the president had taken on a whole room full of high powered Republicans and come out on top- dominating them with his command of policy, public speaking ability, and Vulcan/ninja/Jedi debate skills. And, in fact, it seemed like the president handled himself quite well, and did, in fact, sort of come out on top in the whole exchange by virtue of not only his willingness to take part of this sort of thing in the first place (the media couldn't stop referring to the Republican gathering as the proverbial "lion's den") but also handling himself quite well during the question and answer portion.
In the end, though, I still couldn't help but wonder what the president realistically stands to gain from the whole thing. After this meeting at this retreat, it wasn't as if we immediately saw an outpouring of newfound bipartisanship and cooperation from the Republicans. Instead, they seemed to mostly be complaining about the format of the event (they were unhappy that the camera remained mostly fixed on the president without giving more camera time to the Republicans who were asking questions in the audience, and they were upset that there wasn't more opportunity for rebuttal and argument about the president's responses to questions). In short, the Republicans didn't seem to really listen to the president's message so much as they spent most of their time figuring out how they could tilt the battleground to their own advantage the next time one of these events occurred- which is a little ironic on an occasion when the president has elected to speak to the opposition party in the interest of fostering bipartisanship.
I respect the president's nobler instincts (I liked his recent quote about being more interested in being a good one term president as opposed to a mediocre two termer), and I think that he's probably really trying to do the right thing by seeking trying to foster greater bipartisanship (it's not only good for the country to see that it's leaders aren't at each other's throats, but, in a practical sense, maybe we could get more done with a little cooperation), but I'm still afraid that Obama may just be wasting time and effort by trying to get the Republicans to support things that are on the Democrat's agenda.
As the president keeps pointing out, there are certainly differences in viewpoints between the parties, but there are also many areas where the parties could find common ground (e.g., we don't agree about a public option for health care reform, but we might be able to come to agreement on the need to stop insurance companies for denying coverage because of pre-existing conditions). The president's thinking is that we could get some significant work done if we could just set aside the things where we differ and move forward in the areas where we find agreement, regardless of who sponsored the original legislation and regardless of who's in power at the time when the bill is moving through the legislature.
The problem is that this runs counter to Republican political strategy. For many years now the Republicans have relied upon a scorched earth, slash and burn approach. Their tactics seem to rely upon obstructing and opposing every Democratic proposal that comes up (while simultaneously riling up their base with propaganda implying that everything the Democrats do is evil), and then campaigning on the fact that the Democrats can't get anything done. And, unfortunately, this seems to have worked pretty well for them. Combine this set of campaign tactics with a fairly pervasive Republican belief that things can only get better when there's a Republican in office, and it starts to look like the president might be fighting a very strong uphill battle.
What the president needs to do is to focus his political speaking skills and powers of persuasion on the American public. The only way that the Republicans are going to change their attitudes is going to be if the voting public starts to put pressure on the GOP to change their ways and meet the Democrats halfway on some stuff. The president is probably never going to win over many converts from the hardcore conservative base, but he might be able to win over enough unaffiliated independents to start putting some real pressure on the Republicans. From what I've heard, most polling data suggests that independents are pretty fed up with the bickering between the two parties. They want to see more cooperation from their leaders. If Obama extends the olive branch and the GOP just slaps it away, their popularity among ind pendents may start to wane.
Undoubtedly, this is what the president wants. His meeting with Republicans was kind of a no brainer from a strategy standpoint. He goes into the thing asking for more cooperation. If the GOP ends up cooperating, Obama has made progress. If they don't agree to cooperate, hopefully they lose the support of independent voters who decide the outcome of elections in this country. So as long as Obama could hold his own and look like a reasonable man, this Republican retreat thing was a good idea for him. His target audience probably wasn't actually Republicans, but the independent voters out there who were watching the whole thing and waiting to see if both parties could play nice.
Personally, my thinking is a little more cynical. I think that the only thing that American voters really tend to understand, support, and care about is success. On things like health care, I tend to think that the Democrats might have been better off just going to the mat and pushing the thing through, even if they had to do so in a completely partisan way. The public might not be too happy about this initially, but once the public began to see positive changes in their health care system as a result of the bill, I think they would have come around to supporting it after the fact. People are almost always afraid of and against change until after they've seen it accomplished and realize that it actually really can benefit them (I see this at work all of the time. Everything from personnel changes to new computer programs to new buildings are always met with cries of horror, frustration, and gloom and doom wailing, but almost invariably, things don't fall apart once the changes are made, and usually people are happy with them once the changes have been made and people have had a short amount of time to adjust to them). So, I think that the president ought to consider, from time to time, simply pushing some things through and letting the chips fall where they may. If the programs are good, they will end up selling themselves. If the programs are bad.... well, you don't want to back bad programs, but the Democrats need to be exercising extreme caution in that regard, anyway (so as not to waste time, resources, and money).
Anyway, I think that the president might be better off just counting the Republicans out and just focusing on getting stuff done under Democratic power. That being said, it's undoubtedly a risky strategy. The Bush White House more or less went it alone for 8 years, but in the end they had a pretty crappy record to show for it and the ineffectiveness of their programs and their policies ended up costing the Republicans a lot of votes as Bush left office. Still, if the Democrats really believe in the policies and programs that they're pushing, they just might need to act first and worry about support later.

Hoo boy. I'm tired, I think I overblogged today.
Rap at ya later.

4 comments:

Unknown said...

Such bs that there is no Grammy's review here. Total bs, dude.

Larry Lee

J.S. said...

Sorry to report that I didn't see the Grammy's this year. One of our caseworkers was telling me that there were some pretty good performances this year, though. I'm still a little skeptical of the Grammy's, since I still think they tend to be geared more toward slaes figures than the artistic merit of music, but I think they're probably getting a little better about trying to recognize music that might end up actually having some lasting appeal.

Unknown said...

Dude, the Grammy's are objectively awesome, a celebration of all that is good and bad about music. Pure spectacle. I realized this when I attended the American Music Awards in person one time a few years back. It's wildly entertaining. And so I started paying more attention to the Grammy Awards.

Some might say, "My misguided brother, Milli Vanilli won a Grammy." To this I would respond, "Exactly." It is precisely because Milli Vanilli won a Grammy that you should watch the Grammy Awards. To wit: this year watching a wildly off-key Taylor Hicks and Stevie Nicks butcher a duet of a Fleetwood Mac song was one for the ages. I mean that is priceless television right there. Where else can you get that but the Grammy's? Also, people shouldn't expect too much from music or the awards that seek to recognize it. Save that crap for the Tony Awards, which rightfully, almost nobody cares about and nobody watches. Can you really trust someone who enjoys watching the Tony Awards. I mean, really? Can you? Yet, you can certainly trust someone who watches the Grammy Awards, at least a majority of the time you can. Plus, you should never miss a chance to see Beyonce. Only a fool could deny the power of Beyonce...

J.S. said...

Guess I missed out. "Objectively awesome" might be a bit of a stretch. As for seeing famous people put in kind of mediocre performances- doesn't American Idol give us that almost every week? And wait- why am I supposed to trust someone who watches the Grammys? My problem with the Grammys, of course, is not only that they give music awards to acts like Milli Vanilli, but, probably more importantly, they regularly miss the opportunity to highlight musicians who are actually really good. There's a long list of great artists who never won a Grammy- Neil Young, David Bowie, The Doors, Led Zeppelin, Bob Marley, Jimi Hendrix, The Who, The Grateful Dead, and even Diana Ross. The list goes on and on. Other times, the Grammys simply recognize great artists late in their career because it would look stupid not to- Bob Dylan fell into that category (of artists who put out great material but who the Grammys were too out of touch to recognize when the material was new).
So, the Grammys are, for most intents and purposes, just mainstream pop culture junk food. And television is so full of that already. I know that they've claimed to be making more of an effort in recent years to reward artists who might have a lasting appeal as opposed to just rewarding short lived acts that sell a lot of records, but I'm just not convinced they're there yet (Kings of Leon won album of the year? I have the album and I've seen them in concert. They're just sort of a middle of the road band. The album was okay, but fairly derivative- at their best I thought they just sounded a lot like U2- and their live show at ACL Fest was really pretty lame).
But it is what it is, and I'm sure it can be entertaining. I just don't think that the entertainment value should be confused with importance.