Also, there's this weird case being publicized in the media over the last 24 hours here in Austin where a young mother was arrested for poisoning her 3 year old child over at Dell Children's Medical Center. The child had been hospitalized, would start to recover, and then would start to get sick again. Medical personnel got suspicious, and they set up hidden video cameras in the girl's room. The mother, Emily Beth McDonald, was caught on video putting human feces from a diaper into the child's IV line. When the mother was caught, she admitted that she knew that such actions were likely to make her daughter seriously ill and that there was a significant risk of death associated with infections from such behavior.
I bring this whole thing up not just to gross everyone out, but to point out that this seemingly bizarre behavior has a longstanding precedent in the mental health community, and, in fact, there is a disorder called Munchausen Syndrome By Proxy (otherwise known as Factitious Disorder By Proxy) in which parents (typically mothers) take actions to harm their own children (or other people in their care) or make them sick, with the theory being that they are seeking the sympathy and attention that is often afforded to parents with sick children. The idea of harming one's own child in order to get more attention seems bizarre to the point of being nonsensical to most people, but this disorder has been observed and studied for a pretty long time, with some of the earlier observed cases actually involving the introduction of urine into a child's blood (other cases involved poisoning through excessive salt and other strange ways of harming children). The diagnosis is not entirely without controversy (especially by people who get upset about the thought of abusers trying to escape culpability for harming a child by way of a medical diagnosis), but it is listed, nonetheless, in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual IV (the sort of cornerstone book for the diagnosis of mental illness) as a real disorder (although it is designated as one requiring further study).
It's also kind of interesting to note that McDonald wrote an essay in 2007 for the Austin American Statesman about the fact that she had suffered depression after the premature birth of her daughter and about how she had felt overwhelmed by the amount of care that her daughter required.
Anyway, I'm not mentioning these diagnosis as an excuse for this woman's behavior. By all accounts, she was perfectly aware that her actions were likely to harm her child and that they could, in fact, prove deadly. Also, a person who's intelligent and insightful enough to write an essay for the newspaper about her own depression and the difficulties of child rearing ought to be capable of picking up a phone and calling for some help if they're truly overwhelmed (call the hospital, call Any Baby Can, call a counsellor, call family, call friends- just call someone and ask for help, and don't give up until you get connected with someone who can help).
I'm not at all saying that this woman deserves a free pass just because she might have a disorder. Some disorders involve a lack of conscience or empathy, and they can lead to people doing some bad things. That's not to say that bad behavior on the part of the person with the disorder should automatically be forgivable. We all have impulses to do things that we know are morally wrong at one time or another, but we control (or try to control) those impulses because we know its in our own best interests and the best interests of society to do so (for reasons ranging from a desire to maintain the social contract to the preservation of our own mental health to the simple fear of punishment). People with some disorders may have impulses that not all of us share, but that doesn't really give them the right to indulge those desires.
So I'm not trying to excuse abusive behavior, but I think that there may be ways to understand it better (i.e., bad behavior occurring in people with personality or other impulse control disorders), and maybe to both spot it and prevent it (as well as to treat people with these conditions so that it doesn't happen again).
I've gotta run, but I thought this was an interesting case. I'm sure we'll be hearing more about it in the Austin media.
3 comments:
Such a strange story. The woman definitely has issues but I don't think that should stop her from being prosecuted. She clearly can differentiate from legal and illegal actions. I wouldn't say she's a sociopath but there is something very narcissistic and sociopathic about Munchausen Syndrome By Proxy.
Steanso--
I'd be interested to hear the legal take on this lady. Should she be allowed to keep her child? Should she be prosecuted?
My opinion: Part of the problem with psychiatric diagnosis and the DSM IV....it's all very vague and subjective. Especially when you get into some of the Axis II (personality) disorders that NTT mentioned--- schizoid, antisocial, borderline, narcissistic, etc. disorders. I'm
I can look at a biopsy under the microscope and say "This is lung cancer" and run all sorts of genetic analyses on the tissue. You really can't do that with psychiatric problems. Maybe that's why I never liked psychiatry.
And where do you draw the line between personal choice and attributing everything to some DSM IV category/medical condition? I'm sure there will be some psychiatrist out there who will claim that this lady suffers from a medical condition and should not be held responsible for her actions....
Yeah, the question of when to hold people legally accountable for their actions is obviously pretty complicated, and whole books could be written on it (and have been). Most of the cases that I deal with on my docket are actually Axis I stuff, which seems to typically have a more clear cut biological component to it than the personality disorder stuff (you can actually see that a schizophrenic's brain pattern looks different than a normal person's when you're looking at EEGs). In general, the standard for holding someone legally responsible is whether or not they were aware (or were capable of being aware) of the difference between right and wrong action (legal or illegal) when they engaged in their behavior. Often, people with personality disorders understand the difference between right and wrong from an intellectual standpoint, but they just don't have the same emotional reactions to situations that everyone else does (a lot of their issues are more emotion-based than cognitive).
To be honest, insofar as we do things around here, we mostly treat people with personality disroders the same way we would treat anyone else. Part of this is because of the difficulty in diagnosis (as you pointed out), but part of it also stems from the fact that even a lot of doctors typically agree that people with personality disorders need the to hav e their understanding reinforced that there are very real and very serious consequences for their actions, particularly actions which affect other people. Axis I behavior can frequently be changed pretty radically and relatively quickly with medication, while the personality disorder stuff seems to also require extensive, long term therapy in order to treat. To be honest, a whole lot of the people in our jail probably have personality disorders, but most of them are undiagnosed. We might take personality disorders into account to some degree when deciding sentencing, but we generally don't let people off the hook because of them. For doctors who are going to show up and advocate the position that we need to acquit all people with personality disorders, I would argue that that line of reasoning would then require us to lock all of those people up in institutions in order to keep the rest of us safe. If you want to keep those people integrated into society (which is actually the more desirable goal, of course), you have to allow for the fact that these people can and should be held responsible for their actions.
Post a Comment