Happy Friday.
Here's something from yesterday's paper that I meant to comment on, but never got around to: Austin's police chief, Art Acevedo, is recommending a plan that would call for the installation of surveillance cameras on 6th Street, and along 12th Street, Chicon Street, Rundberg Lane, Lamar, and Montopolis in East Austin soon after.
I have some seriously conflicted feelings about this. On the one hand, the whole scheme kind of conjures up Orwellian images of a police state with no privacy for its citizens and government surveillance that monitors each person's actions every moment that they're outdoors. I have paranoid visions of a future in which vans wheel up to the curb and whisk citizens off to government detention every time someone spits on the sidewalk. I think of state agents sitting in darkened rooms, watching video monitors and keeping track of the connections between citizens, tracking who has been seen with whom in order to protect against potential anti-government collaboration. The idea of ongoing street level surveillance makes me nervous.
On the other hand, it would be nice to be able to respond in a timely fashion if a person were suffering some emergency and needed immediate assistance (but for some reason wasn't able to call it in). Similarly, it would be nice to be able to cut down on street crime (particularly violent crime, and/or property crime) by virtue of having more eyes available to spot such activities and to dispatch officers.
My paranoia may seem sort of far fetched, but keep in mind that once a video system is installed, it probably isn't going away (I imagine that the equipment will be maintained and upgraded, but once it's in place, I would guess that it's probably there to stay), and there's really no telling how the police or the government will be using their surveillance tools 10 or 20 years down the road (if someone had told me that all of the stuff in the Patriot Act was going to be legal ten years ago, I wouldn't have believed them). And how useful would these devices be for day to day police work, anyway? Do we really have that many citizen emergencies occurring that don't get called in by cell phone or landline? Are we going to be able to prosecute street level drug deals that we see on camera when all we can really see are some small, hidden objects changing hands? Can we positively identify prostitution activity just because we see two people conversing?
Surveillance of Sixth Street might seem to make the most sense, given the relatively high number of drunken assaults and other alcohol-induced tomfoolery that goes on down there every weekend (people tend to do dumb things down there, and are probably too intoxicated to realize or care that they're on camera when they're acting up), but I would bet that conclusive evidence of most street crime will be difficult to catch on video once the defendants figure out that surveillance cameras are trying to record their actions.
Like I said- I'm conflicted. I'm a prosecutor, and it sure would be nice to have a nice, clear, close-up photo of the guy breaking into your car or taking a drunken swing at you outside of some bar, but the civil libertarian in me isn't crazy about the idea of the government documenting every moment that I'm outside, recording who I'm with and what I'm up to. I don't need a government video existing somewhere that shows that I occasionally litter or pee behind a dumpster after a concert (these are, of course, merely hypothetical examples...).
Anyway, Austin's a pretty well-educated city with a lot of citizens who are attuned to the pros and cons of these sorts of issues, so it'll be interesting to see how the whole thing plays out. I hear that London already has pretty comprehensive video surveillance, and Londoners have just come to accept it and deal with it as a fact of life. I really have no idea whether the surveillance has had much of an impact upon their crime rate, though.
Not much else to report. I had dinner with Team Steans last night. The Mono Ensemble is supposed to play at a party this Saturday, so that's cool.
That's it for now. Maybe more later.
Peace.
2 comments:
I can appreciate the question of allowing the police to keep surveillance on an area. I would not be opposed to a pilot program on 6th street, just to see how the Austin cops would use the technology, and how attorneys could use the information that could be provided to them. However, rather than deal with the trial period as just the first step to warm Austinites up to the idea, I'd prefer to see the results debated and discussed before any further money is spent. After all, if the cameras provide no statistically provable results, I'd prefer the city not continue to throw good money after bad. Further, after the debacle of GoogleMaps' pictures being placed, I'd want to see very specific guidelines for how the video would be used.
I sort of shake my head that they'd need to put cameras on Rundberg. I know the areas has become pretty sketchy, but I don't see the likelihood that hookers are going to hang out in front of cameras providing their services, or that dealers will stand in camera range plying their trade.
I think it would be a good idea to legalize drugs and prostitution in certain run-down sectors of Austin.
And only in those sections.
We could call it "Hamsterdam"
Post a Comment