Last night I went out to dinner with Ryan, Jamie, and Jamie's parents, Dick and Judy. We went to Threadgill's and I had chicken pot pie. It was nice to see them, and the chicken pot pie was pretty good, too.
Other from that, I didn't do too much. I took Cassidy for a walk, watched a bit of TV, and blogged about Mitt Romney.
And, of course, this whole story about the CIA destroying videotapes of terror suspect interrogations rather than handing them over to the courts, Congress, or the September 11th Commission kind of disturbs me. It conveys the image of an intelligence service operating without oversight or regulation- believing itself accountable to no one and apparently willing to violate the law in order to serve its own ends.
The fact that the CIA is destroying material that constitutes evidence would be troubling under any circumstances, but when it's destroying evidence that relates to interrogation practices, the agency's behavior becomes downright chilling.
People on this blog have taken exception to the fact that I've referred to U.S. interrogation practices as torture, claiming that we engage only in "extreme interrogation techniques" that don't rise to the level of human rights abuses that constitutes torture. Well, it's pretty hard to feel confident that our government isn't engaged in questionable activities when they not only refuse to allow outsiders any access to interrogation activities, but they're actively engaged in the process of destroying evidence of their interrogation sessions.
And the claim that the tapes were destroyed in order to protect the identities of the interrogators is ludicrous. The tapes could have easily been modified to blur out the faces and voices of the interrogators before any portion of the tapes was to be made public. If MTV can blur out name brand logos from tee shirts and ball caps for The Real World, then I'm pretty sure that the CIA can get access to the same technology.
Anyway, the torture debate is ongoing and the question of whether it is sometimes justified (and under what circumstances) remains open, but the actions of the CIA in destroying material that was clearly meant to be evidence (both in the federal trial of accused terrorist Zacaria Moussaoui and in the legislative inquiry of the 9/11 Commission) is absolutely inexcusable.
Why do I doubt that our justice department is going to spend a lot of time investigating this matter, though?
No comments:
Post a Comment