Wednesday, May 02, 2007

So not a lot to report on again. Last night I went and ate Mexican food with Ryan and Jamie. Afterward we hung out at my place and ended up watching a PBS Frontline documentary about Mormons, of all things. It was really interesting (did you know that you can be baptized after death in the Mormon church and that The Book of Mormon holds that a lost tribe of Israelites relocated to the Americas, where they built large cities?). OK, so it wasn't the most riveting evening ever, but it was kind of nice.
So how about this new proposal to let concealed handgun owners carry their weapons onto school campuses? The arrogance and foolishness of this bill astounds me. The argument has essentially been that the Virginia Tech massacre wouldn't have happened if the students on that campus had been armed. This may or may not be true. My feeling is that if there had been armed students at Virginia Tech, then any would-be killer would have just upped the ante and used bombs or fully automatic weapons instead of pistols. After all, he planned this thing out for weeks ahead of time, so surely he would have had contingencies if he would have known that some of his classmated might be armed.
More importantly though, I think that if we had a law in place allowing for campuses full of armed college students, this one school might have avoided this one atrocity, but there would be a slow, steady stream of gun related deaths throughout the course of the year, not only from this college campus, but from many other campuses which have never suffered any attacks. College students already cause enough problems when they're drunk, angry, depressed, lonely, or just partying too hard (think of the number of DWIs, drunken brawls, dating violence, hazing incidents/pranks gone wrong, suicides and so forth which lead to problems every year on college campuses). Now imagine having guns thrown into the mix during this period of emotional volatility, excessive intoxication, and experimentation. Imagine all of the times you saw people doing stupid stuff during college that you knew they were going to regret later. Now imagine that there were plenty of guns on hand at that event.
And what about high schools? Eighteen year old kids may not have picked up a criminal conviction yet (or produced any of the other telltale red flags that would prevent them from getting a gun), but that may not mean that they aren't gang members or have an axe to grind with their fellow students. I'm sure that students, as a whole, will fell much safer knowing that the Bloods and the Crips sitting next to them in their history class are armed to the teeth. And we know that Jimmy wouldn't shoot Johnny just because he slept with his girlfriend, right (because hormonally charged eighteen year olds are well known for making reasoned, carefully thought out decisions, right?).
Here's the thing. It would be a great world if people only acted upon decisions which were made rationally and logically after some careful thinking, but the real world just isn't like that. People make dumb decisions and act foolishly all the time (the jail is chock full of people who didn't think before taking some emotionally charged, stupid action). Most of the time stupid decisions can be rectified. With firearms, those split second decisions have permanent consequences (even more importantly, they are consequences which have their primary effect not upon the shooter, but upon the people in the world around them).
I can't even believe I'm even having to write this. Rick Perry is just trying to pander to his right wing base, and he's come out once again proving that he's a fool. We need far, far less guns in the world. Not more.
You can have your soapbox back now.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure how I feel about students on college campuses carrying guns to class. But I think there is a different argument for professors. That's a debate I would like to see.

However, every time there is an extension of gun rights (conceal and carry in a state, et cetera), people offer dire predictions of shoot outs and Wild West OK corral fights. Those predictions have simply not been true.

J.S. said...

Well, the predictions about armed citizens stopping crime haven't been borne out, either (and I think the number of accidental gun deaths and suicides by firearm have increased fairly steadily in states that have relaxed their gun laws). And so far people have been barred from carrying guns into some of the places that they're most likely to get into trouble with them (schools, bars, etc.). I think concealed gun permits are a bad idea in the first place. I think that allowing guns in schools and bars is just crazy.

Anonymous said...

Well it is not enough for students to carry the guns to school, but upset, bipolar parents as well. This week we had an upset mother who met with the principal at our elementary Title I school. The mother told the principal that she shot and killed an intruder in her home and she was not afraid to use her gun again. People like this do not belong in a school with a gun. We caught two 5th graders that have brought guns to school this year and they are not suppose to be there. Can you imagine what it would be like if they were permitted? Having worked in public eduacation for 31 years and at a Title I school for the past 18 years and enjoying it, I will definitely stop if guns are aloud on campus. Karebear

Anonymous said...

You rock.

Anonymous said...

I for one welcome the resignation of any teacher who wishes to quit, if that teacher cannot correctly spell the word "allowed".

Just kidding Karebear :)

Peabo

J.S. said...

Well, she spelled aloud correctly, but she used it incorrectly. Technically it sould have been something like: "Jeff Peek is a smartass." Oh, wait. Did I say that ALOUD? ;)

Congrats on the new bambino, Peabo!!

Anonymous said...

Hey Jeff,
Congratulations on your new son. I can't wait to see him!! The first time we are in Austin, we have to see the little fellow.
Karebear

Anonymous said...

As with many issues, people seem to be pretty well evenly divided and entrenched--either you love guns or hate 'em. Few will change their minds when a tragedy arises. Instead, both sides use it to thump the podium and say 'told ya' so.' The comments do indicate a general agreement:(a) that college kids are pretty impulsive, excitable, and irresponsible and that most of us (even those who are pro second amendment) are a little uncomfortable with the idea of people toting around anything more dangerous that Foucalt in their backpacks; and (b) that if someone is really determined to do something horrible they will plan a way to do it (knives, pistols, full auto, bombs, , etc.)

These two areas of agreement being established, acn't we agree that the argument is different for arming professors (or security guards or someone). Shouldn't there at least be a few people on campus who have proven themselves over a long period of time to be level headed and willing to shoulder some responsibility for the collective good who can be trained and armed so that when the inevitable nut job shows up with a Glock something more effective than barring the door and jumping out the window. I think that if a large public institution with lots of funds in its coffers decides to bar the general public from using arms to defend themselves, then they have a corresponding duty to take affirmative steps to make sure that if a nut starts shooting (or slashing, etc.) that someone has the ability to do something more effective than playing dead, jumping out a window or barring the door and acting as a human shield.

Ask yourself this question: Would you be more or less comfortable on a plane knowing that there is an air marshall on board?

J.S. said...

Right. Yes. I would be more comfortable with an air marshall. Which leads to the corresponding analogy that I would be more comfortable with additional campus security or police. Your analogy re: armed professors is more akin to asking armed pilots to be responsible for defending the plane.
Another potential problem that I see is that perhaps (and I'm totally generalizing here) the majority of professors might tend to be pretty left leaning and not all that interested in carrying a gun around with them. I never asked for a show of hands in undergrad, but I have a hard time imagining most of my philosophy professors pulling out a handgun and duking it out with an armed lunatic.