Sunday, May 27, 2007

Baby Boomers, The Future, and the Skepticism of The Admiral

I specifically remember having a conversation with my father back when I was in either late high school or early college, when I had read a couple of articles predicting the fact that the members of Generation X were going to be the first generation that, on average, did not have an income level or a standard of living that was as high as their parents had previously had. I remember this conversation because The Admiral pretty much rejected the idea, stating that he thought it was just another gloom and doom media forecast, something meant to get people riled up and create a controversy, but probably not a solid prediction of what was going to happen in the future. (just for the record, The Admiral isn't the kind of guy who typically rejects reality as it's reported by the "liberal news media" or anything like that, but he has a healthy skepticism about what he reads in the paper, and in the case of media predictions and prognostications I think he's right to be a little suspicious, as oftentimes these predictions are slanted to suit the political aims of the groups who are offering them)
Anyway, The Admiral thought that with a little elbow grease and the continuing American know-how of the next generation, America's economic dominance would continue and that our generation would rocket forward into the future with the same success that every previous generation has enjoyed (each prior American generation having out earned the one before it).
A study was released this week, however, claiming that American men in their thirties are now earning less than their fathers did at the same point in their own lives, and that family income growth has similarly slowed. The study was based upon U.S. Census Bureau figures, and it shows a 12% drop in income for American males between 1974 and 2004, a stark contrast to the figures in 1994, at which time males were making 5% more than their fathers had made in the generation before. (family income, at first glance seems to have faired a little better, but it actually is on the decline when you take into account the fact that most American homes now have 2 income providers working to produce a household income, whereas in 1974 the general tendency was still a single income provider for most families)
These results come at a time when the U.S. economy is generally considered to be fairly healthy, but they also help to demonstrate the fact that wealth distribution in the U.S. continues to develop in a way which disproportionately favors the wealthy over the middle class. (the outsourcing of U.S. jobs and the structuring of employee compensation packages all contribute to this phenomenon)
Anyway, I'm not here to cry about my job or how much I'm paid (I actually like my job, for the most part, and I've picked a field of work which I am truly interested- there are other areas of the law which might be more lucrative, but I think I'd find most of them pretty dry), and I have no idea how my specific salary compares to what my dad was making at my age, but I think this article does shine a light on some interesting features of the relationship between Generation X and the Baby Boomers (or other prior generations).
This income disparity is just the beginning. The Boomers are rapidly moving into retirement age, and by virtue of their numbers, they'll soon put a massive strain on Social Security, welfare, medicare, and just about every other government "entitlement" program that we have out there. And this is about to occur at a time when our government is already operating with a massive budget deficit and incredible amounts of debt. (I've heard Boomers complain about the fact that there's not going to be any social security system left by the time they retire even though they've been paying into it throughout their working lives, but the leadership of the Boomer generation is also the group which has been responsible for creating a system of government that has been operating at a deficit for decades- minus a few moments during the Clinton years when we seemed close to balancing the nation's budget for a moment). I'm still not clear as to how Generation X, a generation fewer in number than the Boomers, is supposed to shoulder the increased tax burden that will probably be required in order to keep our social infrastructure viable.
But the Boomers may not go quickly or quietly. Boomers are retiring later than any previous generation, thereby reducing or delaying career advancement opportunities for the subsequent generation, while simulataneously, of course, delaying the opportunities for the salary increases which accompany such promotions.
Anyway, I'm not here to say that the sky is falling or that Generation X needs to round up all of the Baby Boomers and put them out to pasture, but I am saying that our society is about to face some interesting challenges as the Baby Boomers move into retirement and Generation X comes into its own. I think that, ultimately, The Admiral was like most Baby Boomers in wanting to reject the prediction that Generation X was bound to face some difficult times. He didn't want to believe that America might offer less opportunity and present more challenges for our generation than it did for his own, and he certainly didn't like the idea that his generation might be contributing to our difficulties. But here we are in 2007, and some of the predictions about the difficulties facing Generation X are starting to become reality.
There will be tricky times ahead, and you Boomers are going to just have to bear with the Gen X'ers as we work through some things.
Now if only the parents within my generation can find a way to forestall some of these problems long enough to push them off onto the next generation...

14 comments:

Carla said...

Great post.

J.S. said...

Thanks, CB. When are you going to be back in Austin? I get so confused....

Anonymous said...

In fact, everybody I personally know my age who is doing well (has a strong income with chance for improvement) has (for the most part) worked their tail off, either through education or hard work in their trade - or both.

The people I know in marginal jobs, or struggling to find a career, or not making a strong income, I would have to say for the most part is due to their own mistakes and or shortcomings.

The U.S. economy, is not merely "fairly healthy". We are seeing record economic heights being reached and record low unemployment, record tax revenue being received by the government, in the midst of fighting a war costing us billions every month.

The growth and opportunities are out there in unprecedented ways. If people can not find a way to become wealthy or semi wealthy in the United States, I am sorry but I don't have a lot of pity for them. I am amazed at how many people thought they could just go to college and get a degree and then they would automatically land a good job and have a great career, because that's what their parents did. There is a lot more to it than that.

People need to do a better job of being able to look at themselves objectively and ask, "what about me is marketable ? What can I really offer to an employer ?"

I know far too many people who think they can walk into an interview with a degree and a few years working somewhere and that they should get a job.

I think what the numbers may start to prove is that there may be a slight drop off or stagnation when looked at as a whole, but there are far more people from our generation who are rizing to the ranks of being wealthy than the Baby Boomers. There are more millionaires being made now every year, and at greater percentage rates, than at any time in history. And this is not all trust fund babies, and lucky dot.com wonders, it is hardworked, ingenuitive people who were disciplined in their study and astute at seeing the market evolve, and have busted their tail and spent and saved and invested wisely.

I will never understand this country's obsession with at the same time wanting to be wealthy, and the despising the wealthy.

Most companies who have wealthy executives, and even smaller companies who have wealthy owners, are going to compensate fairly their talented employees....not just employees, their talented employees, because that is what makes companies, of any size great.

If a worker feels he is not being compensated enough, perhaps he/she should look at his/her own talent level, and then perhaps the light would come on as to why. These companies would never be able to continue to grow and generate wealth if they were not retaining and fairly compensating employees.

The poor are poor because they have chosen to be so. And yes, I am aware it is easy to make that statement when one has been born into privelege, even limited privelege, such as I. But my status and education were not handed to me. I worked to get what I have. Perhaps others have had to work harder and overcome more obstacles but the opportunity is there none the less.

There is a quote from Calvin Coolidge I read, and have kept close by, because I really believe it to be true.

“Noting in the world will take the place of persistence. Talent will not, nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with great talent. Genius will not, unrewarded genius is almost a proverb, education will not, the world is full of educated men who are unsuccessful. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent.”

Anyway, just a thought.

Peabo

Carla said...

I move back the 1st. Yipee!

J.S. said...

Poor people are poor because they choose to be poor? Wow. WWJD?

Peabo, you're claiming that we don't live in a socially stratified society, and yet, from what I've seen, a huge part of your law practice is comprised of making money off of non-English speaking, typically undocumented aliens who are tagged as non-citizens with no rights, no matter how hard they work. This is who you make all of your money off of, at the same time that you proclaim this to be a country of unbridled opportunity!!

Plus, let's not even go into the amount of money that's necessary to go to law school...

You kill me, Peabo, you really do.

Anonymous said...

WOW is right, Jason.

If you have the opportunity, money and intelligence to go to law school, medical school, engineering etc, of course you are going to work hard and then get a good job. Those of us with Liberal Arts degrees don't have it so easy and do have bust our butts trying to figure out how to make a living.

And don't get me started on the response to "the poor are poor because they have chosen to be" statement. Please ...that is a ridiculous statement. No one wakes up and says "you know what ....I'll be poor". Our country is FULL of the "working poor" who work hard at minimum wage and still can't work their way into the middle class.

The old American dream is much harder to achieve these days. If our country cared enough, it would get it's act together so that ALL kids receive an excellent education growing up then maybe everyone would have a an equal opportunity at acheiving their version of the American Dream . But that is clearly not the case in our current society.

-MGW

J.S. said...

Damn. Peabo even got Mandy mad. And that's saying something.

Anonymous said...

Okay maybe my reading comprehension is not as good as it should be, but your original post was decrying the fact that there appears to be retardation of economic advancement (in terms of wages) and perhaps even in opportunities from the time the Baby Boomers were young and in the workforce compared to now. Your opinion was based off of a study showing that our generation is making less (percentage wise) than our parents were. I reply by saying I think that I think there must be a problem with the study based on other studies showing economic growth in every sector and increasing and record numbers of middle class wage earners becoming millionaires based on investing and hard work.
I get a reply with somewhat of a personal attack insinuating WWJD and then a veiled insult and implication that I am somehow taking advantage of low income undocumented immigrants and thus making my living off the poor ?
Please tell me I misunderstood that. I believe we are educated adults and as such we can debate the merits of an argument without personal attacks or insults.
What would Jesus do ? Is that an attempt to say that as a Christian I should have empathy with the poor ? That I should spend my time looking out for them financially and make efforts to extend them a hand in love to leave their situation ? Well, I agree 100% and I do my best in the form of financially supporting an indigent orphanage in Mexico, financially supporting ministries at my church in which we feed the homeless and let them sleep in our church building and provide them access to jobs and counselors. Surely you weren’t making a judgment on somebody personally without knowing anything about how they give their time and money. Although myself and my church are by no means perfect we make an honest attempt to live up to Christ's teaching on reaching out to the less fortunate and oppressed.
Jesus taught us to reach out and help the poor, but he also did so in light of Jewish teaching on work ethic and discipline found in the Old Testament. Go read proverbs and see what it says about lazy and undisciplined people. Poor people who are oppressed, or sick or infirmed, or orphans or widows, are not to be confused with those who are not taking time to make the most of their opportunities. You may think quoting from spots in the bible make a cute point, but the truth is Christ did not come to abolish Jewish teaching, but to live it in truth and love and in doing so he chastised those who claimed to love him but did nothing for the poor, but I don’t think people making 20,000 a year, with televisions and cars, living in air conditioning, with plentiful meals everyday, were who Christ was talking about when he said “poor”.
However none of that is relevant to what I posted or what you stated in your post. So although you might have felt it a nice little retort and commentary on my faith and its apparent hypocrisy, it really just showed to be a petty and way off base comment that had nothing to do with my statement.
The poor choose to be poor not by the birth or their circumstances, but by their decisions throughout life into their adulthood. I have plenty of friends who grew up in poverty and escaped it being the first ever in their family to go to college. What is the difference between them and their peers Jason ? My wife grew up dirt poor by our standards in Mexico to 2 parents who were each 1 of 8 and 9 children respectively who did not have one, NOT ONE SINGLE FAMILY MEMBER, who had ever been to college or made more than 15,000 dollars a year. By any standard available, they were poor. She and 2 of her sisters worked their butts off in school and in jobs to move ahead. Her father, who sold gum in the streets as a child, worked his ass off to give the more opportunities than he had. Through hard work and discipline they are managing to escape poverty.
Which leads us to the "oppressed" undocumented immigrant. You may want to trust me on this Jason, as I promise you - having lived in Mexico, worked in all immigrant churches for the past 7 years, and married to and part of a Mexican family, that I know what I am talking about. I don’t appreciate you making accusation or even insinuation that I am somehow taking advantage of these people. They are more than my clients. They are my friends, they are by brothers and sisters in Christ, and now they are even my family.
Have you ever been to my office ? Have you ever talked to even one of my clients ? Are you aware of the numerous monthly community events we go to and offer free legal advice ? Are you aware that we are sponsoring a scholarship for the children of Immigrants who are to be first time college students ? Are you aware that our fees are significantly…..significatnly lower, than the current market rate, as well we never charge consultations ? Are you aware of how many cases we take pro bono or at such a reduced rate to not even make a profit on ?

Before you such reckless and unwarranted disparagement, on a friend no less, just because we may not see eye to eye on a social issue, you might want to think about it first. I don’t appreciate it.
I stand by the work I do here and am proud of what my firm has done with the immigrant community. We have taken on fraud against immigrants from fellowbar members who borderline rob immigrants due to their ignorance, against Notarios and Car dealerships who we have personally taken on pro bono, we our gold member sponsors of Casa Marianela who helps shelter and feed recently arrived immigrants with no income or family support. We have offered for years to any Hispanic who is buying a car or home to bring in their contracts in English so we can review them for them and explain/translate them and we do this ABSOLUTELY FREE in an effort to battle against fraudulent business practices that target the immigrant community. WE do our best to make sure we are part of this community and not merely making money off of them.
I will stand on my reputation. You can ask any of my current or past clients, or any number of the numerous community groups, from the Mexican Consulate to El Buen Samaritano, to a host of local churches, to neighborhood groups, and ask them what the reputation of Los Abogados Gueros is.
Your comment is totally unsubstantiated, insulting and untrue, even if it was an insinuation.
To finish the only part of your reply that vaguely addressed the point, is that it is a land of opportunity. Were you trying to be ironic in your reply ? Do you not realize these immigrants who come to this country “with no rights” (laughable at best) are probably making more money than the average Government employee ?
I have clients in construction who have been here 10 years and are making over 50,000. They own houses, and property, some even have their own businesses. Some will forever be day laborers and that is mainly due to their education. But even the “day laborer” can go on to make over 40,000. Not be because he is bright, or has access to privilege, but because he works his ass off. Which was my whole point. The hard working disciplined and dedicated individual will succeed and will never be poor.
My comment about the “poor choosing to be poor” was for here in the U.S. anyway. Mexico is a whole other can of worms, and there is systematic oppression over there and lack of access to education that does not exist in this country. As are other third world countries were war, famine, disease are truly unfortunate obstacles to a fair chance at success, so I certainly hold them to a different standard.

If you want to talk about “poor” you will not find much sympathy from me referring to people in the U.S., a country with so much opportunity for everyone it is ridiculous. The real poor can be found in Africa, Central America, the middle east, India and China. That is a true poverty. It is insulting to them to call anyone in the U.S. poor.

Peabo

Anonymous said...

Mandy, you and I will have to agree to disagree. I know plenty of liberal arts majors doing fine in their respected fields. I also know others who struggle. Each made decisions to put themselves on their respective paths. None of the are "struggling" financially. They may not be able to buy as big a house, or take as fancy a vacation, but they made the decision to choose their career.

Again, I disagree with on the choice to be poor. Not the choice in who you are born to, but the choice to decide to take advantage of the opportunities one is presented with. In every inner city, ever poor urban area, loaded with young people dropping out of school, or getting by with C's and D's, and going home to play with friends or watch 5 hours of t.v., in that very same school is a kid who will be going to college. IN fact there are thousands of kids like that all over the U.S. who are in the same crappy schools, have the same tough family situations, and yet they are managing to make decision that will lead them to success. Some through genetic brilliance, others thru dogged determination.

You appear to believe that a choice has been forced onto them. I disagree. I believe an environment has been forced onto them. They still choose and have only themselves to answer to.

I feel for the kids, and that is why I have spent a lot of time the last 10 years working with kids who live with single moms, and are on that fringe and have spent time mentoring them. My wife and I have both done it and are passionate about it. But I tell you it is an uphill battle when they have parents who are such horirble examples.

All we can do is put our hand out and try to make a difference. But I am a firm believer in personal responsibility and this wanting to blame or point fingers, or say poor me for my circumstance just enables the poor and uneducated to continue their cycle of poverty and ignorance.

Just one man's humble opinion in the trenches.

But I don't appreciate it when people from lofty ivory towers throw barbs at me. My hands are dirty and I am out their trying to make a difference. Perhaps you are too, but don't I can't stand people who have such passionate "beliefs", and are sitting on the sidelines casting dispersions from their comfy seat in suburbia.

You want to make a difference, give me a call and I'll get you hooked up with a mentoring program tomorrow. That is if you aren't already involved in one.
Peabo

J.S. said...

Peabo, you have reached ridiculous levels of posting on my blog. Time to go away and get your own blog. Or you could just save some time and post a lot of "dittos!" on Rush Limbaugh's site. I hear that he's a wise, wise man.

J.S. said...

There are enough things in Peabo's rantings to literally write a book in response to, but I just want to limit it to this.
1) I'm willing to discuss the representation of illegals in Travis Co. with you any time. My actual comment was about the fact that there are people who you represent every day who are second class citizens through no fault of their own, and who are working hard and trying to make their lives better. Sometimes people ARE born into circumstances which seriously limit their options and their ability to move forward. Still, I'm willing to discuss this topic further in a non-blog setting.
2) I'm glad to hear you do a lot of volunteer work. I used to do more of it and I need to get back into it. Nonetheless, no amount of volunteer work gives you the right to think you're better than anyone else or to sit in judgement of them. And when you couple your religiously-based volunteer work with comments like "Poor people choose to be poor" it makes non-Christians seriously question your motivations. (do you really want to help people, or are you just trying to indoctrinate new members into your church or earn some kind of self-interested ticket to the afterlife?) Sounds like the Jesus you worship might fit into the Republican camp. The Jesus I was raised with was more interested in securing the welfare of other human beings than meting out judgment against the poor. Even though I don't attend church all that much these days, I still like my Jesus more.
3) Politics ARE personal. They reflect some of our most deeply held values, and the way we want to see our ethical beliefs reflected in society. You shouldn't be surprised if political rants earn emotional replies.
4) I understand that there are slackers and loafers out there, and I don't want to give them my money, either. I just don't think that a good portion of America and most of the third world deserves poverty and is looking to hustle everyone else the way that you seem to.

You still need your own blog.

Anonymous said...

Sorry for posting anything that doesn't agree with you lockstop. I don't know how people are going to be able to go forward in this country when friends can't even sit down and discuss things.

Look, you know I love you, but you are way out of line. You have done nothing but throw personal attacks at me which is uncalled for. You can't even have civilized discourse without the "Rush Limbaugh" and "WWJD" cracks. Then you try and denigrate my faith.

Lucky I answer to a wiser judge than you. I am not sitting in judgment on anyone. In fact the only one I have seen sitting in judgment is you on this thread.

It is also apparent your "jesus" is just that. I didn't write the bible, I just merely reference some passages. I agreed with you 100% on our duty to reach out and try and help the poor. I also referenced the fact that Christ was a Jew who very much believed and followed the same laws the Jews did which called for personal responsibility, discipline, self control. I am sure there are many other teachings of Christ regarding fidelity, celibacy, personal sacrifice for the good of others, that you also might not be in agreement with and that's fine.

Then you throw at some comment about the nature of the motive of Christians service.

Look man, I can't help you. I am sure in your eyes that the hundreds of hours I have spent working with young men and women in a mentor capacity, the thousands of dollars I have spent to ministries serving those in need......and the billions if not trillions spent by Christians worldwide in projects for AIDS relief in Africa, to Habitat for Humanity, to soup kitchens, food pantries, Clothing stores, etc. are all just are plot to further the cult. It has nothing to do with our genuine love to serve out fellow man.

Get over yourself. Your personal opinions on christianity are as just as off base as your opinions on me.

I am not saying these things to somehow brag to you or show off, I am saying them because I won't listen to you run down my genuine efforts in the hispanic community and my genuine faith with your tired cliches about Crhistianity.

And quit assuming because I am Christian I am some sort of Republican. Another off base stereotype which you are apparently prone to. I have voted more Democrat and Libertarian in the last 8 years than Republican.

Wrong again Mr. Steans.

But the floor is yours, nor more dissenting will apparently be tolerated, so I'll shut up.
Peabo

J.S. said...

Hey. I'm really sorry I offended you. I'm not anti-Christian, and I think it's a beautiful religion. I know you're a good person, and I'm not questioning all of the good work you have done, and not really your motives, either (in spite of our arguments, I have to agree that I know you better than that). I just got really enraged to hear you saying poor people are poor because they choose to be poor. That statement infuriates me, especially when I hear it coming from someone that I really do have to admit is a pretty good person. ;) It makes me just shriek internally, "How can he really believe that?" How can a good person believe so little of other people and seem so indifferent to their problems? That is honestly what I ask myself when I hear you make a statement like that. If my attacks seem personal, it's just cause I'm trying to demonstrate with personal examples why I can't believe you would make such a statement. My religion is humanity, and I think that your statement shows an utter lack of faith in humanity. That's why I got so angry.
I know you're a good person, and I'm venting against you as a symbol of things that have just been bothering me for a long time.
I'm truly, truly sorry.
Of course you have a right to believe whatever you want. I also have a right to argue with you very vigorously, especially on my own blog, but I realize I have overstepped my bounds. I apologize.

Anonymous said...

Well I do have to comment. No I have not made a comment on this subject before. I do not believe poor people choose to be poor. Teaching English to adults, on a volunteer basis at our church and now in our home during the summer has led me to people who work very hard and very long hours. Yet they are only making minimum wages which does not make them wealthy. I am taking one of my students shopping today for a crib and essentials for their first baby to make things easier for them. Carlos works 12 to 14 hours a day, 6 days a week and Nancy works at least 10 hours a week 6 days a week. I just want their baby to have some things that our neighbors have for their children. Nancy and Carlos are as good a couple as anyone else or better. The families of students in my elementary classrooms throughout the years, have worked hard and yet struggled financially because of low wages. I came from parents who were from another country, not high school graduates, but now I have a Master's degree, two sons with college degrees. My parents worked very hard and we had a decent, but not an extravagant life. It was easier for me to get ahead. Yes, I paid for my own college education but it was $250.00 a semester my freshman year and I lived at home. Things have changed. Families have a difficult time making ends meet, children have a difficult time paying for college themselves, and jobs are difficult to get without a college education. One more thing, when the admiral started working at Ford Motor Company with a master's degree, he made less than our neighbor, with a highschool diploma, that worked on the line (hourly). The Roberts had more money than we had because he made time and a half and double time with overtime. The admiral worked compulsory overtime, with no extra pay. These line jobs no longer exist in the United States. Everything is being done overseas. Yes, the Admiral and I do discuss this at length as his company like all U.S. companies have too many factories and business overseas, as far as I am concerned. What we have left here are minimum wage jobs. Pretty hard to support a family of four on minimum wages. Well this is enough of my rambling.
Yes, some people do make mistakes or have shortcomings. I did not know there was anyone on this earth at the present time who was or is perfect. I do not think the person who has made a mistake or has shortcomings chooses to be poor.
Karebear