Wednesday, July 26, 2006

Hey, guys. Work is getting a bit easier as I work my way back into old routines. I caught a quick bite to eat with DK at the sandwhich shop next to the courthouse during lunch. It was good to see her. DK is one of those people that other people (including me) want to tell their problems to, even when I'm not really sure DK's up for hearing them. Anyway, I hadn't really seen her since before Jeff's accident (she was out of town at the time of the funeral, and is still feeling like the whole thing is pretty surreal, and I assured her that I felt the same way). Anyway, it was good to catch up with her.
Not too much else to report. Jackbart and Kate came over for dinner last night (with Mandy and Camille, of course), and it was nice. We ate some kind of lasagna (sp?) and some chocolate mousse stuff that Jackbart brought and then sat outside and talked about the Da Vinci Code and other stuff. The weather was nice, and it was good to hang out with them.
Also, it is apparently newsworthy that Lance Bass of 'N Sync fame is gay. I'm not sure why this is newsworthy, and I'm sure that it would be far more shocking if someone were able to confirm that the other members of 'N Sync were definitely not gay.
Also, Andrea Yates is found not guilty by reason of insanity in the murder case against her for drowning her five children in a bathtub. The verdict shocked me, but I'm really not prepared to say that the jury did the wrong thing. It's easy to see how a jury might think that a woman would have to be out of her mind to do such a horrible thing. But then again, I would say that someone has to be incredibly sick in order to molest children, but society doesn't seem ready to cut those offenders any breaks. I don't know- the entire criminal justice system is predicated upon the notion of personal responsibility, but mental health issues draw that notion into question (i.e., if you're too sick to know what you're doing, how can you be held accountable for your actions?). Anyway, I hope that Yates is held in a mental health institution for a long, long time.

10 comments:

The League said...

I still am not clear on how anyone thought she wasn't nuts. I'm no PhD, but I sort of thought methoodically drowning your 5 kids because you think God told you it was a good idea was probably a good indicator that something was amiss.

Anonymous said...

Methinks there will now be a great deal of discussion of the insanity defense in the news and in the legislature. -JD

Sigmund Bloom said...

where should Yates husband be kept for a long long time?

Anonymous said...

The think Andrea Yates' husband should have had to pay some type of consequence for this tragedy. He had the poor lady living in a trailer first with many children. Next, Andrea suffered from depression and yet they continued having more children. Another thing that upsets me, with her depression and recurring mental problems, Rusty had Andrea homeschooling their children. She was kept in their home with 5 children. No one likes children more than I do, but having "mental problems", a husband that controls you, and being with 5 children all day, everyday would drive you over the edge. He did not help her mental state at all. I truly believe this verdict was the correct verdict.

J.S. said...

It probably was the right verdict. I guess my concerns deal more with the way that the mental health system interacts with the justice system. The thought that someone might declare her "rehabilitated" in a relatively short amount of time and then reintroduce her into society is kind of scary to me.

Anonymous said...

It's a tough call. On the one hand, in 1st year criminal law, you are taught that there are two parts to a crime: the "actus reus" or criminal act and the "mens rea" or guilty mind. In Texas, the mens rea is defined by statute. For most offenses, you need to show the culpable mental state behind the person's action: intentional, knowing, reckless, or criminally negligent. I think most people would agree that this makes sense. The culpable mental state distinguishes between unintentional and intentional conduct.

On the other hand, the Yates case is tough because of the extreme nature of the criminal conduct. It seems the definition of evil to murder your own children in such a systematic fashion. No one will deny that Yates was clearly mentally ill. The question is whether her illness was such that she could not form the necessary culpable mental state to commit the offense.

Most people have never been around someone with active severe mental illness. I had a client once who was deep in a psychotic phase of schizophrenia. It was the weirdest thing because the things that he saw and the world in which he lived (one where movie stars visited him regularly and reporters pursued him relentlessly), was very real to him. Nothing you could say would convince him otherwise. The experience really helped me see the reality of severe mental illness. It's not just somebody "faking it" to get off.

I guess the frustrating thing is that when you do have someone who's mental illness makes them extremely dangerous, we don't have a way to make sure that society is protected from them. Many people respond well to psychotropic medications, especially the newer ones, but outside of a secure setting, there is no way to make sure they stay on their meds. At the same time, our legal and mental health systems are just not set up to handle long term placements for these people outside of prison. Remember the guy in Beaumont who was found not guilty of murder by reason of insantiy and placed in a mental institution. At some point, they determined he was well enough to be released. Then he went and killed his girlfriend's son and stuffed him in an oven.

Sorry for the long post. I guess my point is that if we are going to accept the idea that a person's mental illness can be severe enough so as to excuse even the most heinous crimes, we have to be committed to the long term care of that person so that they and society are fully protected. I don't think the yahoos in the legislature or Governor Goodhair are interested in mental health to the extent that they are willing to spend the dollars and the political capital to come up with an effective long term solution for this problem. Until they do, we are going to see our jails continue to be the primary mental health care provider.

Anonymous said...

Does anyone remember the defense lawyer the McKenzie brothers had in Strangebrew? The guy who busted out the karate and kicked ass on the mob of reporters outside the courthouse. I thought of that because, like the prior post, that guy also explained the requirement in criminal law that a guilty verdict requires a finding of both "acteus reus" and "mens rea." Also, FYI, for anyone who likes the Grateful Dead and Phish, I highly reccomend the 4-15-99-4-17-99 run that Phil Lesh did with Trey, Page, Steve Kimock and John Molo. Find it for free on Nugs.net.

Steanso, I remember a post where you described rumors that Gary and I were "lurking" withjout posting comments. I'm sure this post will make you and everyone else wish that I were still lurking.

Anonymous said...

i don't know who jlo is, but i feel as if i've received a mini-education in law. thanks, jlo.

J.S. said...

I don't think that NGRI excuses you from your actions simply because you believe that you're "doing the right thing" for your children- I think you have to lose the ability to distinguish between right and wrong. I think the courts have found that parents cannot deny lifesaving medical treatment to their children, even when they are doing so for reasons based upon religion (which would seem to mean that they believe that they are "doing the right thing" even though they know that society disagrees with them). I think that the phone call to the police in the Yates trial indicates that Yates knew on some level that something extremely troubling was definitely going on- the question was more a matter of how much capacity for reasoning she had at the time of the crime. The fact that she somewhat "came to her senses" enough to call the police following the crime doesn't necessarily mean that she fully understood her actions at the time of the drownings, though.

J.S. said...

Lunch, it sounds like your "understanding that others would not see it her way" amounts to a recognition that she knows that she's violating the law (you can say that she just knows that she's doing something which falls outside the conventions of the society, but ultimately I would argue that laws are nothing more than codified versions of our most important societal conventions, and that if she knows that she's doing something that most everyone in her society would see as horribly wrong, then she knows that she's breaking the law- even if she thinks she's doing the right thing). Are we arguing in circles here?