Friday, February 20, 2009

S'up? Anyone out there? What's going on?
Beeeeeeautiful weather today in the ATX. Hope it holds up through the weekend.
I know I've kind of beat this stimulus package thing to death, but there's a pretty good editorial in Newsweek this week by Jonathan Alter about the stimulus package and the partisan response that it's gotten and why the whole thing is kind of symbolic of a larger problem that we're having in which the most radical members of each party (i.e., the wingnuts) seem to be somehow dictating what the parties do (Alter has a suggestion for trying to remedy this problem by changing the way that primaries work in many states- essentially having multiparty primaries where the top two candidates, regardless of party affiliation, end up running in the general election against each other. You'll have to read the article yourself to get the details and see if you think his idea is justified or plausible).
And I guess the Academy Awards are on Sunday. My brother, aka Roundball, aka The League, aka Ryan, seems to have some sort of pathological distaste for the Oscars which he has been attempting to recast as some sort of philosophical, ethical objection. I'm not sure of his exact line of reasoning, but it has something to do with a lack of objective criteria for handing out the awards coupled with an inappropriate amount of focus placed upon movies that come out late in the year combined with a lack of imagination or vision on the part of the judges which results in them picking the same "types" of movies year after year. I guess I understand his basic criticisms, but when he took the next leap of logic into the realm of asserting that these flaws created some sort of moral obligation for people to not watch the show, I parted ways with him.
I will say, however, that I agree that people, in general, take the Oscars way too seriously and give them far too much weight in terms of assigning critical merit to a competing film. The Oscars, at their heart, are just awards handed out to because some questionable group of people (yes, I'm referring to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences as a questionable group of people) happened to like them.
Personally, I don't think that the Oscars do a very good job of rewarding innovation or true artistic vision (the academy is much more concerned with choosing safer, more traditional films), and they don't necessarily do a good job of predicting which movies or performances will really stick with audiences and become classic favorites over time (some go on to be classics, but others- not so much. We've all heard of the "Oscar curse" in which an actor or actress never seems to repeat the supposed success they had when they won their Oscar, but in truth, what this often reflects are those occasions when the academy has handed out awards to actors or actresses who just weren't that great in the first place).
Anyway, people should still enjoy the Oscars for what it is- a chance to see the stars come out and party with each other in the most glamorous clothing that Hollywood can produce while watching film clips from some nifty movies. And sometimes the hosts and presenters can be kind of entertaining.
But let's not take the whole thing too seriously, shall we? After all, most of us have spent a lifetime watching movies, discussing movies, and analyzing movies. Many of us have education levels that are higher than half of the people who are part of the voting academy (working in film has traditionally not been one of those occupations which has required higher education in one's background, so you sort of get a mixed bag with people employed in the film industry- the largest segment of the academy voting block is comprised of actors, and there are a whole lotta film actors out there who don't need a lot of wall space for their diploma collection). Some of us rubes out here in the middle American viewing audience even have degrees in film and/or have written our own screenplays (ok, here's your nod Ryan and Jackbart). My point is that significant portions of the American viewing audience is, in many instances, probably every bit as qualified and competent to judge movies as the members of the academy, so I can kind of relate when Roundball gets a little worked up by the pomp, circumstance, and self-promoted gravitas of the Oscars. The academy isn't really qualified to tell us what the best movies of the year were, so much as they've just gotten good at selecting certain kinds of movies (typically something with just the right mix of some artistic integrity, widespread marketability, and typically a touch of a moral lesson thrown in for good measure).
So this year, eat your popcorn, watch the pretty dresses, but try to keep in mind that somewhere out there Roundball is losing his mind because the Oscars are once again rewarding the same old crap.
That's it for now. Have a good one!

2 comments:

The League said...

Hey, I didn't even get worked up into my usual lather about how the Red Carpet and celebration of people who essentially don't do any actual work is representative of what seems to me to be an ingrained desire to place mere mortals on a pedestal they don't deserve. Short an actual monarchy in the US, the Oscars are the hallmark of an artifical and disposable system of allowing the staff around a few quasi-talented actors dictate what we should value (fame by any means necessary and narratives which re-inforce basic moral lessons we learned in grade school).

It doesn't help that the system is so obviously gamed at this point that movies released any time before December 15th don't stand a chance, or that industry peer pressure to see certain movies, actors win , influencing voting, etc... dictates the winners. It all more or less devoids the awards of meaning or substance.

Its all just not much of an achievement. And yet billions tune in to see hackey musical numbers, actors flub lines off a teleprompter, jewelry worth enough to feed every man, woman and child on the planet, and just god-awful speeches in which actors, during their moments of greatest success, are essentially lobbying for more work (why do you think they thank all those studio people who you never heard of)?

It's embarassing.

Unless they'd nominated Dark Knight for best picture. Then, you know, all would be forgiven.

J.S. said...

Like I said, Sunday is going to be a long night for Ryan...