Monday, January 12, 2009

Well, the weekend was pretty good. Friday night I went to see F for Fake at the Carousel Lounge. As usual, they were really good. F for Fake isn't really about crazy solos or technical pyrotechnics, but they're really good at just creating cool melodies and diggable grooves (and their songs usually have great lyrics). The only problem with the gig was that F for Fake got a late start because the prior bands ran late, and then the bartenders cut them off at midnight, so it was kind of a short set. Oh well. Better to leave people wanting more, I guess.

Saturday morning I went with Ryan, Jamie, and a handful of close friends down to Barton Creek at the spillover by Barton Springs. Ryan scattered Mel's ashes, threw a tennis ball and a few milkbones into the creek, and we all said goodbye. There weren't any speeches or anything. We were the only people down on the creek, and it was very quiet and peaceful (and it's a very nice spot, with the water, and the birds, and the trees). A fitting goodbye for Mel, and we'll think of him whenever we go down there (Mel loved to swim down there, and Cassidy, Lucy, and the rest of us still enjoy the place, so we'll be back in the future many times, I'm sure- although when it's a bit warmer).

After saying goodbye to Mel we went over to Shady Grove and had a very nice lunch with all the folks who went down to the creek. My brother wrote about the experience on his blog if you guys want to check it out.

Saturday afternoon I finally got around to going to see Milk with Ryan and Jamie. It was a really good movie, and Sean Penn put in an amazing performance. While the struggles of the gay rights movement are far from over, it's pretty amazing how much progress the movement has made in a relatively short span of time (I say this in comparison to the civil rights movement for blacks, for example). Also impressive is the fact that their advances have been made without bloodshed (gays have been victims of hate crimes, but there have been few, if any, records of violent riots or other public incidents of explosive rage) and the gay rights movement has often been carried on with a surprising sense of humor and grace. Anyway, Gus Van Sant did a good job of telling Harvey Milk's story in a frank, realistic sort of way, without resorting to melodrama or artificial theatrics, and Sean Penn did a great job of inhabiting the character.


Sunday I just ran errands with Ryan and Jamie and hung out. Got a couple of shirts and some other stuff.


Looks like Carol Keeton Strayhorn is going to be running for mayor here in Austin. I'm not really excited by that possibility at all. First of all, I just don't think she fits the city well. I know that she was Austin's mayor from '77 to '83, but times have changed. Austin is a young, vibrant city which thrives on the exploration of new ideas, and I see Strayhorn as a past-her-prime career politician (mayor, railroad commissioner, comptroller, a run for governor, and now mayor again?) who has switched parties and run for every state job imaginable just in order to stay in the public eye and in order to continue to hold public office. Strayhorn is pretty good at calling out her fellow politicians and "taking stands" on issues, but I just don't see her as a person of vision or someone who seeks office out of a desire to serve her constituency. I remember when she was comptroller, and she enjoyed staging events such as cash seizure raids at Antones when they were behind on their taxes. Such public raids didn't come close to covering the late taxes owed by the club owners and didn't really do much to solve the overall problem of small business tax delinquency (which was an issue at the time), but by taking money out of the registers and taking the cash that was collected at the door she insured that the innocent people who were working at the club (including the bands) that night didn't get paid the money they were owed (or at least not in a timely fashion). Strayhorn's critics said she spent most of her time in the comptroller position trying to set up a run for governor and otherwise looking around for other possible positions to run for. She switched parties in order to run for governor (which I'm rarely in favor of when someone's doing it to try to get a new job- I think it shows a potential lack of commitment to one's principles and a possible lack of loyalty), and she really didn't bring any new ideas of her own to the table during the election (like I said, I haven't seen a lot of strong leadership or new ideas from the woman, but she seems to just love a good ol' negative campaign). Anyway, maybe I'll change my mind somewhat as things progress, but I'm really not excited about the Strayhorn mayoral announcement. I'm open to comments from people who know the woman better than I do and who want to defend her. Maybe I'm wrong.

And finally, I watched the two hour season premier of 24 last night. First off, let me just say that from a political standpoint, I continue to have totally mixed feelings about that show. 24 takes place in a parallel reality where all of the crazy conservative stuff that people like Dick Cheney believe in seems justified. On 24, America is constantly under seige from extremely competent, well-funded, well-trained terrorist cells that are operating within our borders. Situations constantly pop up where torture seems like the only option available in order to retrieve information, and the clock is always ticking in a countdown to some armageddon-like event. Our agents always have the best interests of the country at heart, and they're almost infallible in their reasoning skills and decision-making. On 24, we see the need for decision making of the most brutal kind, but we feel secure in knowing that such power lies in the hands of Jack Bauer- an agent with pure motives, sound decision-making skills, and at least some respect for human life. As a viewer, I'm a Democrat who's fairly left of center, and I still find myself cursing the cowardly hippies who would dare to question Jack's motives in torturing terrorists.
In the real world, however, I can't help but feel that the "clock ticking, world on the brink of the abyss" scenarios of 24 are much, much less common (I would think that such scenarios would appear once in a lifetime, if ever, for most real-life government agents), but that torture will tend to be used as a lazy man's interrogation method in any number of less urgent scenarios by operatives who prefer it over more time consuming interrogation techniques or by people who simply have a lot of hositility toward their captives. And then there's the fact that, frankly, I wouldn't trust most agents the way that we all feel that Jack Bauer can be trusted. Agents, like police detectives, can probably get swept up in the pursuit of their goals or targets, and its probably not in our best interests to put so much unchecked power in the hands of people operating under questionable objectivity (while torture may seem to be absolutely necessary to an involved agent who is pursuing a particular goal, the use of torture in that same case may be highly suspect to an outsider who may question whether it is essential with that particular informant, or who might, in fact, question the value of the entire case in relation to the need to torture people in order to accomplish its ends). An even more cynical writer might imply that some government agents could be more interested in advancing their careers by breaking open a big case than in protecting the human rights of suspected terrorists.
Anyway, its endless ethical conundrums aside, 24 burst back onto the scene this season in its usual high-octane sort of way, and I quickly found myself caught up in it. It's the kind of show that really sucks you in. Every once in awhile I'll take a step back and listen to the swelling, orchestral music and an isolated piece of over-the-top dialogue and think, "Wow! That's sort of melodramatic to the point of absurdity!", but within the context of a real-time show with a ticking clock, world-on-the-brink-of-annhilation style plot unfolding in its second by second rapid fire manner, the melodrama seems to work. There's just not a lot of time available for subtlety or nuance on 24, and those sorts of niceties are pretty much beside the point.
So I'll stick with 24 for awhile, watching Jack Bauer show those peacenik freaks that his way is the only way to get the job done*. Stupid hippies.

* Actually, on last night's show, to their credit, the writers gave Jack some lines in which he said that the intelligence community needed to have greater transparency (i.e., not make all of their operations classified) so that the American people could intelligently decide how far they wanted their agents to go in "getting the job done". Only when people know the truth about what our agents are dealing with (i.e., how close the real world comes to 24-type scenarios) can they make an intelligent choice about how far agents should be allowed to go. So even Bauer admitted that the question of whether or not to torture shouldn't really be left up to agents in the field (they should have strict guidelines). I thought that was an interesting point for 24 to bring forward.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hey Steanso, I like 24 too, but you should be more open about Carole. She founded ACC, fought to start Capital Metro, began downtown revitalization, passed the first Barton Creek Watershed ordinance, passed the first Fair Housing ordinance. She is progressive and has a long-term vision. Even the Austin Tomorrow Plan she passed as mayor is still used, and she would be the one to pass a new one. As mayor she looke out for all of Austin and especially made sure East Austin was treated right.

J.S. said...

First off, even though I went ahead and published this comment, let me go ahead and reiterate my general distaste for anonymous comments (I don't mind if people don't want to create a log in ID, but that doesn't mean you can't include your name). For all that I know (and from what I suspect), this comment may very well be from one of Rylander's campaign volunteers or supporters who are spending their time Googling her name, searching the internet for people who are talking about her candidacy, and then trying to spin the discussion in the most favorable light possible. (and there's not anything wrong with that, inherently, but it's disingenuous if you don't tell people you're working for her campaign when you go out and speak up for her) Also, Carole may have been involved in the establishment of ACC, but I think it's definitely an overstatement to say she founded it. As a matter of fact, I think most of the measures that you mention are things that other people took the lead on, but which Rylander simply did not oppose. I'm not sure what you mean by saying that she made sure East Austin was treated right. Anyway, I'm happy to hear contrary opinions, but please let us know who we're hearing from.