Friday, December 19, 2008

So it's the last Friday before Christmas. We had a pretty nice office Christmas party last night. Not exactly wild and crazy, but pleasant enough. Today we're having some kind of Christmas luncheon at the church across the street from my office (which seems a little weird, especially for the Jewish kids who work up here, but everyone seems cool with it). I'll be getting some time off the week after Christmas, but I'll be manning the fort up here at the office right up through Christmas Eve. Why the courts are open on Christmas Eve is sort of a stumper, because I can't imagine that anyone's going to really get anything done, but mine is not to question why... (here's a little news flash for those of you who are would-be criminals: don't commit crimes around Christmas time. In addition to being put on Santa's naughty list, the whole court system works at half speed during the holidays, so you're likely to spend twice as much time in jail as normal before getting out if you commit a crime during the time around Christmas and New Year's. There you go. Consider yourself warned.)
Looks like the automakers are getting a bailout, after all. I'm not sure it'll be enough to really turn things around, but hopefully it keeps them alive long enough to do some restructuring and to rework some of their current business plans. Even though gas has once again dropped in price for the moment, I hope American car companies don't go right back to their old habits of building unreliable gas guzzlers (and, yes, I freely admit that the unions are going to have to radically alter their ways of thinking if they want to remain part of an industry that is globally competitive).
And there was a column today in the New York Times about some of the controversy surrounding the upcoming, latest version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, a cornerstone book in the fields of psychology and psychiatry which is used in the diagnosis and classification of mental illnesses, both for treatment and insurance-related purposes (the new version will be the DSM V, and it probably won't come out for another 3 years). The DSM is used widely and almost universally in modern psychology, and the way that the book is compiled and edited sort of fascinates me because in psychology, unlike in most other medical fields, the way that a disorder is defined, in a way, sort of creates or alters the disorder itself. Because most mental illnesses are defined through the identification of symptoms and/or group of symptoms (as opposed to, say, identifying them by way of looking at actual chemical or electrical activity in the brain), certain disorders may literally be defined in and out of existence in the field of psychology. Homosexuality, for example, was designated as a mental disorder prior to 1973. From 1973 to 1987 homosexuality went through a number of different names and a number of different criteria and symptoms were listed as necessary in order to classify homosexuality as a disorder. Finally in 1987, partially in response to growing political pressure and a new societal awareness that homosexuals were every bit as capable of leading happy, fulfilling, productive lives as heterosexual people, homosexuality was removed as a disorder from the DSM. So it's clear that societal norms play a part in defining the existence of mental disorders in the DSM.
Current points of contention include the transgender identity issues as a diagnosis (some transgender individuals don't want this as a diagnosis at all- others think it's important to include it in the DSM so that insurance companies can have a diagnosis to consider when considering whether to pay for treatments such as hormone therapy or gender reassignment procedures). A controversial diagnosis closer to many of our hearts involves binge eating disorders and whether or not to include such a commonly occurring issue as a defined mental illness. Other controversies include the influence of drug companies upon mental health experts as they write the DSM (it has been suggested that the diagnosis of bipolar disorder, once thought to exist exclusively in adolescents and adults, was extended to children in the last edition of the DSM at least in part as a result of the influence of the pharmaceutical industry, which had been developing new bipolar medications), and the controversial fact that the doctors currently working on the latest version of the DSM have all been required to sign nondisclosure agreements while working on the book has also been a point of contention (many doctors in the field question the motivation behind this need for secrecy and insist that transparency would be a far better policy while developing such an important book).
Anyway, psychiatry and psychology are unquestionably vibrant, dynamic, constantly evolving fields, and I've personally seen medications and therapy help people in ways that are nothing short of miraculous (not in every case, but truly amazing things can and do happen). Nonetheless, our relatively limited knowledge of the workings of the brain sort of makes the actual cause and effects part of psychiatry a bit of a mystery. We understand many things about the brain, but much of psychiatry is still a matter of recognizing a problem and then applying a medication or therapeutic technique and watching to see if it works (i.e., whether the symptoms subside). A lot of what occurs inside the "black box" of our minds is still kind of unknown, and it's not always easy to differentiate between different diagnosises. Plus, the reaction that society has to a certain set of behaviors may in large part determine whether we consider something to be a disorder (or determine how serious a disorder it is). You don't really have all of these questions when you're looking at malignant cells under a microscope or when you're looking at CAT scan images of a heart defect.
Well, I'm not sure anyone else was interested in this, but I kind of am.
Anyway, I'll let you guys go. Hope you all have a good weekend.

No comments: