Wednesday, November 28, 2007

And I guess this may be overdue, but some of you have probably noticed the fact that I've turned on the comment moderation feature on the ol' blog. As Reed said the other night, I've now allied myself with "The Man" in censoring free speech.

In truth, I will probably continue to publish the vast majority of comments that I receive, but I've also just finally decided to start exercising a little control over the comments section.

I like hearing from people, and moderating the comments will allow people to comment again without having to register as a blogger (although I still prefer it when people identify themselves and accept responsibility for their blog comments), but the flip side of the "free speech" argument is that I never meant for this blog to be a forum for endless, ongoing, political arguments (or endless arguments of any kind, for that matter). I still want to foster some discussion and allow for viewpoints that are different from my own on the blog, but I want the ability to shut the comments down when they become repetitive, nonsensical, or when they degenerate into personal attacks.

To be honest, I also have to blame my own obsessive/compulsive tendencies for my decision to moderate the comments. I have an embarrassing tendency to get caught in this cycle where I can't let comments go unanswered when I disagree with them, which often leaves me arguing with people far past the point where anyone has anything new or interesting to say, and far past the point where I'm accomplishing anything other than looking like a blowhard idiot. Still, I get this nagging feeling in the back of my mind that people will read some kind of resignation or acceptance into my silence if I let some comment slide that I don't agree with. So I argue on- way past the point where the discussion has ceased to be interesting, informative, or in any way persuasive.

And I don't feel too badly about the comment moderation because my blog was never meant to be used for people to express every thought they come up with- if people want to do that, they can publish their own blogs or go post on some political forum (despite my political rantings, I still see my blog as more of an online journal of my personal, day-to-day thoughts than as a sort of political persuasion and argument site). I'm not trying to censor free speech, but I am trying to exercise some control over the manner and the extent (meaning, basically, the length and quantity of comments) to which I'm going to allow people to express their opinions. The idea of the comment section is s'posed to be to allow people to make quick responses to things that I say on the blog- not to provide a soapbox. Like it or not, the soapbox belongs to me because the blog belongs to me.

Well, I probably went on too long about this, but it involves issues of free speech and restraints on it, and I tend to take those things sort of seriously. Even when they're just taking place on my stupid ol' blog.

3 comments:

The League said...

I'm curious what won't make the cut.

How about: You're a communist and you smell like sardine farts.

Does that make it in?

J.S. said...

Does that mean I smell like a flatulent person who has eaten too many sardines, or do I actually smell like a farting fish? Just curious.

The League said...

farting fish.