Well, last night The Mono Ensemble held a rare mid-week practice to make up for the practice that we missed on Sunday when I was in Houston. Ordinarily we probably wouldn't have worried about missing a practice, but we've got our big roller disco party coming up in mid September before ACL Fest (details are coming soon on that, I promise, but keep your calendars clear for Thursday, September 13th). Anyway, the songs are taking shape and things are looking up for this roller skating soiree. Incidentally, the new amp performed quite respectably at practice, although I spent more of my time on bass than guitar. I look forward to experimenting with it some more and trying to get new sounds out of it as time goes on.
I probably shouldn't comment on it too much, given my job as a prosecutor and a county employee, but here in Austin the trial is currently underway for Laura Hall, the alleged accomplice of Colton Pitonyak, who is accused of having helped dismember Jennifer Cave's body and helping Pitonyak flee to Mexico following Cave's murder. Joe James Sawyer, a lawyer whom I've known for years and who I did a little bit of legal work for when I was first starting out, is representing Hall. Sawyer is one of those guys who just truly loves being a defense attorney. He's a natural born storyteller, a gifted bullsh*tter, and he loves a good fight. (Sawyer has been involved in a number of high profile cases since I started practicing in Austin, including Robert Springsteen from the yogurt shop murders). Anyway, I don't know how Hall's case is going to turn out, and it keeps taking strange twists and turns (the state has already produced a couple of witnesses who claim that Hall admitted to helping Pitonyak), but it sure makes for some fascinating reading. If I get some free moments I hope to sneak over to the courtroom to see a few minutes of the trial.
And there's a state report that came out this week that finds fault with Virginia Tech for the deaths of 32 of its students at the hands of Cho Seung-hui last April. The report primarily faults the university for not cancelling classes or locking down campus sooner, especially following the initial shooting of Cho's first two victims at around 7:00 a.m. in a dormitory. I find it understandable that people are angry and alarmed and frightened by the chain of events that led to this mass murder spree, but it sounds to me like there's a whole lot of armchair quarterbacking going on in this report, and I have a sneaking suspicion that the report is sort of meant to placate the families of the victims rather than provide an objective analysis of events. University officials may have been slow to react in terms of warning students once the killing spree began, but I really think they had no reason to presume that the first two murders in this case were anything other than an isolated incident at the time that they were committed, and university officials and police were in the process of trying to investigate and deal with those murders at the time that Cho went on his broader killing spree. In terms of predicting Cho's rampage, it's true that he had exhibited some signs of depression and frustration, but on a college campus I would say that such symptoms are fairly commonplace and typically don't end up indicating any particular propensity for violence (college students tend to be in a very transitional, developmental period of their lives, and I think it's pretty common for people in that age range to have difficulties as they struggle with issues of identity, social interaction, and academic ability). I guess I'm just rephrasing an old cliche, really- hindsight is 20/20. It's easy to second guess administrators after the fact, but are we really going to lock up or supervise every student who might have emotional difficulties? (by the way, students are probably going to be less likely to seek psychiatric help if they think that doing so will get them tagged as a potential mass murderer) Perhaps the school should have been locked down after the first two murders, but then again, do we really want to restrict the liberty of thousands of other students on campus and disrupt the productivity of an entire university every time there's an incident of domestic violence on campus? (and that's pretty much what the first incident looked like before Cho went on his later rampage- an isolated incident of domestic violence in which police erroneously thought they had a viable suspect. And I suspect that it wouldn't take long for students and faculty to start complaining if the whole university had to be shut down every time an incident of violence occurred on or around campus) It's true that there was a killer on the loose who had not been apprehended, but 99% of domestic violence offenders don't go on killing sprees that kill a bunch of strangers. And what if they had locked the campus down sooner? Is there any reason to think that Cho wouldn't have waited them out (there seems to have been a fair amount of time that passed between the first two killings and the later spree, anyway) or climbed through a window or something to get at other students?
Make no mistake about it- my sympathy goes out to the victims and their families, but I think that there's a bit of a witch hunt here. If anything, I think the university police at VT should have just been better trained and armed and quicker to respond once the shooting started. The civil libertarian in me is sort of loathe to admit it, but better video surveillance on campus probably would have been extremely helpful as well.
I don't know what the solution is. I just hope that Cho's final victims aren't Virginia Tech administrators who get tagged with the blame for this thing after having already suffered through an emotionally wrenching tradgedy.
6 comments:
I agree that surveillance would have helped, but a student with a gun could have saved 30 precious lives.
Your analysis is a good one. However, if the State of Virginia had not declared this a gun free zone, I believe there may have been others on campus that could have prevented some deaths through a quicker response. Law enforcement is always an after the fact reaction and will never respond as quickly as individuals prepared to defend themselves. These mental cases are oportunists and will always seek out areas where they can do their damage without interference. Virginia Tech is only one of many examples of this.
Absolutely!!! Gun policies that provide an advantage for violent criminals and a disadvantage for law abiding citizens should never be established. VT might want to implement the Constitution's Bill of Rights.
Yeah, well, I've already made my feelings known about the cost/benefit analysis of arming a community of booze-guzzling, hard partying college students in previous posts, so I won't revisit it here, but suffice it to say that the "more guns" solution is not exactly the angle that I would take. And I disagree with the notion that Cho sought out this campus just because it was a gun free zone. I think he was just striking out at the people who happened to be closest to him (and who he saw as contributing to the vast majority of the frustrations in his life).
We will never know but I suspect Cho would have had second thoughts about targeting classrooms if he had known that someone else might be shooting back at him. You can't rely on big government to protect anyone just because they pass a feel good law.
Or Cho might have just selected a bigger gun and a few pipe bombs to lob in the direction of anyone firing back.
The University of Texas does not allow guns on campus as a rule. This is not to keep students defenseless, but to have a clear set of rules students are aware of that makes enforcement of the rules completely clear to students and law enforcement. Students were often found to have firearms and were quickly dealt with.
I would much prefer to know that preventative measures are in place, although I can somewhat see the responsible gun-owner's argument.
What makes me question the "shoot back approach" is the item I mentioned before, regarding escalation of weapons on a college campus. Secondly, there's an assumption that shooting back in a crowded classroom won't cause more carnage and/ or friendly fire.
I would also be concerned that Cho or others could obtain a weapons permit in a premeditated scenario. Cho clearly planned out his attacks to the T, as did Whitman at UT. What of the gunman who might have a permit and couldn't be stopped right up until the moment they started shooting?
Certainly guns put lives at risk, and the desire to level the playing field isn't crazy. Clearly the concealed weapons laws in Texas haven't led to the Cowboy-style shoot outs critics predicted. It would be interesting to see statistics regarding how many people were able to actually use a concealed handgun in self-defense.
Post a Comment