Hey there. Hump day. Not a lot going on. I watched about 3 episodes of Deadwood last night and didn't do much else. My stomach was kind of out of wack, so I stayed holed up in my house and just waited to feel better.
I don't feel too much like writing lately, but maybe that'll blow over, too.
The two year anniversary of Hurricanes Katrina is today. I visited New Orleans earlier this year for The Police concert, and the French Quarter and large parts of downtown are mostly back to normal. I asked some of the employees at our hotel about the hurricane damage and how the repair effort was going, and they offered to get me a bus ticket to head out to some of the wards that had been truly devastated by the flooding. They explained that they had a "happy tour" for tourists that visited only the areas that had been undamaged or which had already been repaired, and a "sad tour" that visited the poorer areas of the city which had gotten wrecked, but which hadn't really benefitted from the rebuilding effort. The guy at the desk explained that they didn't really sell a lot of tickets for the "sad tour".
Anyway, it sounds like New Orleans continues to change and evolve in the wake of the hurricane. A number of young professionals have immigrated to the town in the post-Katrina reconstruction era, seeing the rebuilding effort as something of an opportunity to develop new lives and new careers, but they're a small segment of the city's overall population, and they're not likely to replace the 40% of the population which fled following Katrina and haven't returned. The murder rate in New Orleans continues to skyrocket, even with the city's reduced population, and reconstruction continues at a pace which feels frustratingly slow to many of the city's residents. I was in Houston with my folks over the weekend, and there were stories on the news in which reporters were literally traveeling around Houston and asking Katrina refugees whether they didn't think it was about time that they packed up their things and moved back to New Orleans (Houston has suffered an increased crime rate in recent years, and Katrina refugees have been blamed, rightly or wrongly, for adding to growing problems with theft, robbery, and violent crime). Incidentally, most of the Katrina refugees that I saw them talk to said they didn't really have any plans to return to New Orleans.
I'm not sure why I'm blogging about all of this except that I really like New Orleans (I think it's one of the most interesting places in the country, in terms of the way that its history blends so intricately and uniquely with its culture), and it just bothers me to know that it's probably never really going to be the same as it was before Katrina. It also drives me nuts to know that the levees still aren't capable of truly protecting the city, and that New Orleans remains just as susceptible to hurricanes today as it was back in 1995. (we can blow an insane amount of money on some pointless war, but we can't protect one of our oldest cities)
That's it. Sorry to be a downer. That's what happens when I have to stretch in order to find something to blog about.
Hope you guys have a good day.
6 comments:
That's one thing I enjoy about your blogs. Even when you are "stretching" to find something to write about the result usuaully has substance and thoughtfulness. Keep on bloggin'.
TA
The war in Iraq caused a breach in the levees?
The war in Iraq has thus far cost us over $447 billion and has bought us nothing but global ill will and a strategic quagmire. I thought it might be nice to use some of that money to keep one of America's oldest cities from sinking beneath the waves the next time a storm hits (apparently the entire levee/flood control system of New Orleans needs a pretty big overhaul- when I was there last time I saw more than one N.O. resident wearing T-shirts that read, "Would You Fix the F*#king Levees Already?"). You know me, though. I'm just a crazy liberal.
Also, according to the program I watched last night, fixing the levees is a fraction of the cost of what it is currently costing to pay our insurance claims and what federal disaster recovery is having to pay out.
Upgrading them to a level 5, they said, still wouldn't come close to the cost of another hurricane in the area.
To fairly compare the cost of fixing the levees with the cost of another hurricane, you must include the probability of another hurricane hitting the area.
If the cost of another hurricane is another $96 billion and the probability of another hurricane is 1 in 1000, then the government's "expected" cost of the hurricane is $96 million. Since the federal government has already committed $114 billion, it is clear that the feds have spent much more than the cost of recovery for Katrina and much more than the "expected" cost of yet another Hurricane. Also, an additional $3.6 billion has been designated specifically for the rebuilding of the levees. Do you really think the federal government needs to do more? It seems the war in Iraq has not in any way precluded a very aggressive redevelopment program in New Orleans, nor has is it prevented levee reconstruction. As such, I am not sure why issues in Iraq and issues in New Orleans would be mentioned in the same sentence.
Regarding Iraq: The United States is in Iraq at the request of the freely elected Iraqi government. The Iraqi citizens overwhelmingly want U.S. troops in their communities, which is why the U.S. implemented the surge. People can now work and shop and kids can play in the park. IED attacks are down 30% since the surge began. In some areas, attacks have gone from 30 per day to less than one per day. Insurgents are being turned over in mass numbers to troops that are now in the neighborhoods and markets. If you don't believe me, ask Senator Clinton. She was recently forced to acknowledge this, then justified her withdraw proposal by asserting incompetence on the part of the freely elected Iraqi government.
Given the current environment, more progress should be expected. With dedication and patience from the U.S., the Iraqi economy can stabilize, the government can organize, and the army can be trained. More time is a requirement for the new strategy, and I beg you to be patient.
So what's the plan? For us to permanently occupy Iraq with over 100,000 U.S. troops in order to provide a minimal level of security? I'm not surprised that the Iraqis want us there at this point- we've destroyed their security and infrastructure, so where else do they have to turn? The Government Accountability Office this week announced the results of an independent audit in which the new Iraqi government failed to meet 13 of 18 political and security goals that had been established for this country (the White House, of course, launched into their typical spin and counterattack rebuttal). The underlying fact remains that, at best, we MIGHT be able to stabilize the country by keeping large numbers of U.S. troops in place in Iraq, but no one has really suggested with any level of confidence that the Iraqi government will be able to effectively provide security and govern that country on its own anytime soon. And I think the cost we should sepnd on the levees is pretty much whatever it takes. $3.6 billion is laughable in comparison to the cost of this war, and personally, I feel that the job of government is to protect and safeguard its own citizens- not to occupy foreign countries in the an arrogant effort to salvage failed military strategies.
Post a Comment