Just a quick political note on this Sunday morning. After having my head up my...well, anyway, I've been catching up on some news this morning, and this detainee treatment bill that the president is likely to sign into law next week is pretty awful. It basically allows the president to identify enemies, imprison them indefinitely and interrogate them — albeit with a ban on some of the harshest treatments that the U.S. miltary and intelligence agencies have considerd employing — beyond the reach of the full court reviews traditionally afforded criminal defendants and ordinary prisoners.
This is bad juju, people. The president is being given the power to declare someone an enemy and then to hold them and interrogate them indefinitely, all with barely a nod toward any kind of judicial or congressional oversight. This is bad. The president has already been doing these kinds of things already, of course, but he's been doing them without a lot of statutory authority (i.e., he's been acting pretty much illegally). Now we're giving the president the power to identify prisoners (the power to tell us who the enemy is) as well as the power to decide where, when, and to whom the Geneva Conventions should apply.
So in essence, the president has the power to declare that you are an enemy of this nation (without any such allegations having ever been proven in any sort of public trial), to have you arrested and incarcerated for as long as he wants, and the power to have you interrogated in ways which are pretty much blatantly in violation of the Geneva convention (i.e., he's allowed to torture you, as long as he avoids a few methods which were specifically prohibited in the bill).
Adventurers, Steanso has worked within the court system for quite a few years now on both sides of the aisle (as both prosecutor and defense attorney), and here's why I think this bill is a bad idea: the government makes mistakes. Even if you don't believe that the federal government would ever intentionally abuse its power and imprison people merely on the basis of ideological positions which vary from the prevailing, America-friendly norms (and I'm far from confident that the government would never abuse its power given the levels of xenophobia and paranoia that we've seen in this country since 9/11), the simple fact that well-meaning government agents and law enforcement officials regularly make mistakes in arresting the wrong person is enough to make indefinite detentions and interrogations without judicial oversight a very bad idea. We're setting ourselves up for internment camps, secret police, and a whole lot of other bad stuff.
Anyway, Steanso is behind the curve on this one. Usually I would urge you to email your reps, but it's just about too late. Oh well, do it anyway. Or support a group that can take action on your behalf when you're too busy working and rehearsing with your band to notice little things like a torture bill being passed. Darn it.
1 comment:
This is very bad juju.
Our Constitution is getting ripped to shreds, and our credibility in this world continues to slip.
This puts our own soldiers in jeopardy if they are ever captured. Why should another government honor the Geneva conventions with our own soldiers if we're not going to do the same.
"Land of the free, home of the brave" indeed.
Post a Comment