A new poll finds that there is mixed support for the president's illegal wiretapping program.
Here's the thing. I don't care how much support there is for soying on American citizens. It's immoral and illegal, and even if 99 people out of 100 think that it's ok, we still need to protect the privacy of the 1% minority against government intrusion and the tyranny of the majority. The ideal of protecting the minority against majority oppression played no small part in the founding of this country (remember those pilgrims that you learned about in elementary school who were fleeing religious and political oppression in Europe because of their unpopular beliefs?), and we shouldn't hand over our civil liberties now just because government and media hysteria has convinced everyone that there's a terrorist lurking around every corner. Look, people, I'm all about catching terrorists, but I think it would be naive to think the government will restrict their use of domestic wiretaps to their use against legitimate terrorist threats. Ideological opponents of the current administration will come under surveillance as well. The wiretapping program will make it easier for the government to illegally maintain surveillance upon the ACLU, environmental organizatons, anti-war groups, animal rights groups, Muslim anti-defamation groups, and other groups which hold views that are in opposition to the political views of the current administration. A number of these groups already suspect that they have been monitored and kept under surveillance by the federal government, and the ACLU (among others) have filed lawsuits seeking to expose the existence of surveillance programs that monitor American activist programs based on their ideological views. Steanso just doesn't trust the man, and the Bush administration has validated my feelings of distrust over and over again (just for starters, we've got their lies about Iraqi WMDs, their denial of any administration involvement in the CIA leak, and the very existence of this illegal wiretapping scheme).
This has been my fastest blog entry ever. It's 5:01 on Friday and I've got to split. Peace!
p.s.- speaking of reasons for not trusting the Bush administration...
5 comments:
If you're advocating the invasion of privacy of U.S. citizens by the federal government, I would say that the onus is on you to prove that the invasion is NOT immoral.
I seee the right to privacy as a fundamental civil right that should not be breached without a showing of good cause. I think that this right to privacy, althought not expilicitly stated, is implied in the constiution through such things as the requirement to gain warrants before invading a person's home or eavesdropping upon their phone conversations. I think the right to privacy has been recognized by law for private individuals as well, to at least some extent (it's illegal to covertly photograph people in bathrooms or dressing rooms or to shoot cell phone pictures under women's skirts). I think that in non-legal terms, the right to privacy is something which is necessary for the smooth and effective functioning of any society. The right to privacy is the reason we teach children to knock before entering a room, to not read other people's mail, and to avoid eavesdropping on the private conversations of others. I find the invasion of privacy to be immoral because I see it as a violation of a fundamental human right- the right to maintain a degree of personal pricacy for communication, expression, and the development of personal relationships- a zone of privacy within which no one has a right to intrude without permission. I believe this right to be a fundamental and necessary part of the social contract for a free and effectively functioning society (I think that people need to have the space to develop thoughts and ideas without immediate review or censorship, and I think that people need a zone of privacy simply in order to maintain their mental and emotional health and exist as happy, productive human beings). Anyway, it's not a religious belief or anything, but since I don't tend to base most of my morality on religion, I would say that I have to appeal to human rights and social contract for my argument that the invasion of privacy is immoral. Sorry if I got snippy, Jim.
p.s.- and I guess I would say that since there is a perfectly good system in place for placing checks and balances upon invasions of privacy, but that the Bush administration ignored them (by refusing to go to the Foreign Intelligence Court for warrants), I would say that their arrogant refusal to justify their invasions of privacy makes those invasions immoral. I gotta stop myself. Can't... stop... blogging.
For the record, Alito scares the s*#t out of me. The reason, he has never once ruled against a corporation, never once ruled against the US government. He has been quoted as saying that he subscribes to a theory called "unitary executive" that would grant sweeping powers to the President and devastate the system of checks and balances that our founders put into the constitution to prevent tyranny.
As a Reagon administration lawyer, he argued that police should be able to shoot in the back and kill and unarmed boy who had stolen $10 after breaking into a house. As a judge, Alito voted to approve a strip search of a 10 year old girl, even though the search warrant police used to justify the search did not mention her.
I question his personal credibility and ethics too. When answering written questions from the Senate under oath prior to being confirmed as a federal judge, Alito promised he would not hear cases involving Vanguard funds, with which he invested money, yet after he was confirmed, Alito heard such a case.
I could go on and on, but it's too depressing.
I don't trust this guy at all, and the more I have read about his views, the more I have found them to be contrary to the principles and ideas set forth in the constitution. Alito would also scare the s*#t out of our forefathers.
Wow. Weedo's really taking it up a notch in his political arguments. I have to agree that Alito scares me, too. I concur in Weedo's fear that Alito doesn't have enough respect for privacy or civil liberties, and I find his purported allegiance to the idea of a unitary executive troubling (which grants more power to the president with fewer checks of his power). Alito just seems like a "company man" through and through, and I don't see him standing up to protect the rights and interests of the little guy.
Post a Comment